New Official List Discussion

[Fergenaprido]

3 of the 4 lists have been correctly guessed somewhere above. The "silver medal" one still remains unknown.

[beavis]

Two festival lists would have been exceptional. Guess you guys went for a sports list then? Far, very far, less exciting for me in that case

[Tasselfoot]

Two festival lists would have been exceptional. Guess you guys went for a sports list then? Far, very far, less exciting for me in that case

Sports list?

[gunnar]

Two festival lists would have been exceptional. Guess you guys went for a sports list then? Far, very far, less exciting for me in that case

Sports list?

Top 100 curling movies.

[kongs_speech]

= king KONG?

Don't misgender me.

[Knaldskalle]

= king KONG?

Don't misgender me.

Kong's a queen.

It certainly doesn't help me that the Danish word for king is konge - and when used as a pronoun or name it's kong. So technically the Danish name for King Kong should be Kong Kong.

[Torgo]

TIL ..

[Torgo]

Would anyone incorporate this film title into the discussion? I can't come up with something

[xianjiro]

Konga es la Reina!

[Knaldskalle]

Would anyone incorporate this film title into the discussion? I can't come up with something

I thought that was going to link to The King's Speech...

[WalterNeff]

Then there's always this

[Fergenaprido]

Still wrong on that last one.

Adoption requests have been sent.

[frbrown]

The "silver medal" one still remains unknown.

Silver = Argentina?

[PeacefulAnarchy]

The "silver medal" one still remains unknown.

Silver = Argentina?

I didn't understand this one until I read your post.

[yllow]

Silver Bear Berlin then surely?

[Lakigigar]

While a sports list doesn't interest me too much, i don't think there's a sports list yet so, i guess that's allright (aside of IMDb sports top 50). Silver Bear would surprise me if it's not Silver Lion. I think i'm most excited about the Sitges list. And Dovzhenko as i've said is allright too (will be one i have a high rank for by definition of having seen a film from it, tho Man with a Movie Camera will be a check many have).

[John Milton]

Sitges would be a nice addition, and Dovzhenko as well. Saw 13/109 on the latter, so Silver would be pretty far away for me as well. Hope the new lists don’t mess up my Club 500 plans too much, I’m almost there, 18 movies away, it seems.

[Mulholland]

I would be excited for a list like Sitges. And that's not just because I booked tickets to see Sisu about 5 minutes ago.

[monclivie]

You mean this list? https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/mari ... dulcedoes/

edit: ok, silly question, there's no other option

[Tim2460]

Here are the suggestiosn so far ...

ASC 100 Milestone Films in Cinematography of the 20th Century	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/asc+ ... /the_claw/
Film Comment's 101 Film Score Milestones	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/film ... samlowery/
Cannes Film Festival - Caméra d'Or	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/cann ... /panunzio/
Dovzhenko Centre's Top 100 Ukrainian Films	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/dovz ... lms/timec/
Monkeys Fighting Robots' The Best Superhero Movies of the Last 20 Years	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/monk ... rs/mjf314/
Berlin International Film Festival - Best Director (Silver Bear)	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/berl ... ear/timec/
Maria Award for Best Picture Winners (Sitges Film Festival)	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/mari ... dulcedoes/
Encuesta de cine argentino's Top 100 Films	https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/encu ... genaprido/

[Tasselfoot]

And we know that 3 are correct. I'm guessing Cinematography, Ukraine, and Stiges. With an unknown 4th.

[Panunzio]

Tim, I would add the Argentine list to the potentials. I'm thinking we might be on to something with that silver medal....

I hope that is the case -- it's a fantastic list, and seems to check all of the boxes for an official country list! A nice and current one too.

https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/encu ... genaprido/

[Tim2460]

Ha argent/Argentine.. Kinda frenchy play of words... I didn't get it at all... Could be

[Tim2460]

Added the Argentina List above and starting hunting the argentinian films

[Lakigigar]

Maybe more box office lists? If the silver is supposed to refer to money.

[Mulholland]

Still going to hold out hope for a sports movie list. We only have the IMDB list for that.

Not my favourite genre necessarily, but it would be nice to have something a bit different.

Kinda discounted the Argentine connection as we already have a list

[yllow]

There was also a HK list guessed on the previous page (gorilla/kong)

[Tasselfoot]

My holy trinity of new lists:
Music Videos, Sports, replaced All Time Inflation-Adjusted Domestic Box Office

[Fergenaprido]

All four lists have now been mentioned in this thread.

Adoption requests were all accepted.

Everything has been sent to Marijn to do, so adoptions should go live some time in the next week or two.

I've enjoyed all of your guesses and trying to understand the sometimes weird word/image associations my brain makes.

[Lakigigar]

Well no one mentioned a specific sports list so its not a sports list.

[zuma]

Well no one mentioned a specific sports list so its not a sports list.

Whew

[Tim2460]

All four lists have now been mentioned in this thread.

Adoption requests were all accepted.

Everything has been sent to Marijn to do, so adoptions should go live some time in the next week or two.

I've enjoyed all of your guesses and trying to understand the sometimes weird word/image associations my brain makes.

I was so close of the #AllSilver

[Ebbywebby]

https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/scre ... ma/mjf314/

I still think this would be a neat list for adding some new flavors to the ICM canon.

[zuma]

https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/scre ... ma/mjf314/

I still think this would be a neat list for adding some new flavors to the ICM canon.

I agree. I love it.

None of the mods do tho.

[gunnar]

https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/scre ... ma/mjf314/

I still think this would be a neat list for adding some new flavors to the ICM canon.

I agree. I love it.

None of the mods do tho.

Maybe they will slowly come around to your way of thinking...

[zuma]

Haha. Any potential adoption rumination is already as slow as one of those films. It has been brought up and discussed many times in the past decade(?)

[Tasselfoot]

Ignoring any personal opinion on the genre of the list... I'm against any list that is just "here's a fuckload of films that meet a criteria". A list should be a Best Of or significant in some way. It's why I have issue with the Tom Vick Asian list. Or the Action book list.

As opposed to my issue with the 1000 Noirs list, which is a Best Of list... but is too large for the genre it represents.

[Fergenaprido]

https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/scre ... ma/mjf314/

I still think this would be a neat list for adding some new flavors to the ICM canon.

I agree. I love it.

None of the mods do tho.

I looked into this and based on what I could find in mod discussion and in previous forum discussions dating back to 2015, the main issue is the source, not the content. It's a bibliography for one person's thesis paper, essentially listing all the films they mentioned or looked into, and isn't a qualitative assessment of those films.

I think a better list for arthouse/slow cinema would be seriously considered by the mods, but I wouldn't get your hopes up for this particular list getting adopted.

Edit: Tassel just made the same point.

Haha. Any potential adoption rumination is already as slow as one of those films. It has been brought up and discussed many times in the past decade(?)

From what I see, it's only been brought up twice, during the user polls in 2015 and 2021? (maybe there was a third one in between, I can't remember)

[Tim2460]

@Ferge : the new icons are already ready ?

[Tasselfoot]

So if everything is all set on the lists and sent to Martijn... can we get confirmation on what they'll be?
Not, uh, for me... no... but plenty of other people are super impatient, yeah.