iCM Forum's Favourite Animated Movies 2019 (Results)

[joachimt]

iCM Forum's Favourite Animated Movies



Nominations-thread

Thanks to Mulholland for hosting the previous edition in 2014:
results thread
top 500 on iCM
(A top 250 was presented, but there's no top 250 list on iCM.)

Participants: 49Show

1SO
albajos (unranked90)
bal3x
beasterne
beavis
blocho (unranked2)
Caracortada
Carmel1379
cinephage
Cocoa
Coryn
Fergenaprido
filmbantha
flaiky
Gordon_Gekko
gromit82 (unranked25)
GruesomeTwosome
hurluberlu (unranked45)
jeff_v
jiraffejustin
jvv (unranked)
klaus78
Lakigigar
Lonewolf2003
Mate_cosido
mathiasa
max-scl
maxwelldeux
mightysparks
mjf314
Mysterious Dude
Onderhond
Opio (unranked51)
Panunzio
Perception de Ambiguity
rnilsson19
russa03
Smoover
sol
St. Gloede
TajSamKojiJesam
Teproc
tommy_leazaq
Traveller
TraverseTown
wasabi
XxXApathy420XxX
zuma
zzzorf

Top 250 (iCM)
All votes (iCM)

Top 250 (IMDb)
All votes (IMDb)

Top 250 Shorts
Top 250 Features

[joachimt]

I reserved posts #2 and #3 for stats and stuff, but I've posted lots of different stats in between the results. So if you want stats, just browse the rest of this thread.

[joachimt]

reserved

[joachimt]

Just finished collecting 41 screenshots. By going through those alone, it seemed clear to me the results go all ways. I even had to take some screenshots myself from youtube clips of movies with just a few checks. So here we go......



#250 (#new) Fantasia 2000 (1999, Don Hahn, Eric Goldberg, Francis Glebas, Hendel Butoy, James Algar, Paul Brizzi, Gaëtan Brizzi, Pixote Hunt) 138.26 points, 17032 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

beasterne (#57)
Coryn (#35)
gromit82 (#17)
Panunzio (#72)

#249 (-15, #234) Magical Maestro (1952, Tex Avery) 138.37 points, 839 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

cinephage (#1)
Lonewolf2003 (#98)
mathiasa (#203)
Opio (#43)
Perception de Ambiguity (#415)

#248 (#new) The Prince of Egypt (1998, Simon Wells, Brenda Chapman, Steve Hickner) 140.25 points, 33774 checks, 3 official lists, (IMDb)

6 votersShow

beasterne (#35)
Caracortada (#95)
Coryn (#42)
gromit82 (unranked>25)
Mysterious Dude (#34)
Panunzio (#93)

[joachimt]

#247 (#new) Redline (2009, Takeshi Koike) 140.81 points, 1179 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

klaus78 (#47)
mjf314 (#33)
Onderhond (#13)

#246 (-96, #150) Glens Falls Sequence (1937, Douglass Crockwell) 141.15 points, 254 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

mathiasa (#68)
mightysparks (#67)
Mysterious Dude (#22)
Perception de Ambiguity (#109)
rnilsson19 (#27)

#245 (#new) Bully for Bugs (1953, Chuck Jones) 141.2 points, 1774 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

jeff_v (#81)
mathiasa (#56)
maxwelldeux (#13)
russa03 (#37)

[joachimt]

Last batch and then I'm off.



#244 (-70, #174) Memorîzu AKA Memories (1995, Katsuhiro Ôtomo, Tensai Okamura, Kôji Morimoto) 142.06 points, 1296 checks, 2 official lists, (IMDb)

7 votersShow

Carmel1379 (#193)
Mate_cosido (#31)
mathiasa (#177)
Onderhond (#31)
rnilsson19 (#70)
russa03 (#86)
wasabi (#45)

#243 (#new) Lapis (1966, James Whitney) 142.08 points, 565 checks, 2 official lists, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

bal3x (#64)
Carmel1379 (#102)
mathiasa (#85)
Perception de Ambiguity (#9)
rnilsson19 (#46)

#242 (-15, #227) 9 (2009, Shane Acker) 142.28 points, 9346 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

filmbantha (#24)
hurluberlu (unranked>45)
tommy_leazaq (#42)
zzzorf (#26)

[mjf314]

#250 (#new) Fantasia 2000 (1999, Don Hahn, Eric Goldberg, Francis Glebas, Hendel Butoy, James Algar, Paul Brizzi, Gaëtan Brizzi, Pixote Hunt) 138.26 points, 17032 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

beasterne (#57)
Coryn (#35)
gromit82 (#17)
Panunzio (#72)

I didn't vote for this film, but the "Rhapsody in Blue" segment is one of my favorites.

[joachimt]

#241 (#new) Karafuru AKA Colourful (2010, Keiichi Hara) 142.99 points, 362 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

beavis (#10)
Perception de Ambiguity (#41)
TraverseTown (#42)

#240 (#new) The Last Unicorn (1982, Jules Bass, Arthur Rankin Jr.) 144.08 points, 3870 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

Fergenaprido (#42)
Gordon_Gekko (#63)
mathiasa (#55)
Opio (#13)

#239 (#new) Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within (2001, Motonori Sakakibara, Hironobu Sakaguchi) 144.33 points, 10004 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

albajos (unranked>90)
beavis (#34)
Perception de Ambiguity (#164)
zzzorf (#1)

[joachimt]

#238 (#new) Nezha nao hai AKA Nezha Conquers the Dragon King (1979, Shuchen Wang, Ding Xian Yan, Jingda Xu) 144.66 points, 115 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

mjf314 (#81)
rnilsson19 (#10)
wasabi (#22)

#237 (#new) Over the Garden Wall (2014, ) 145.16 points, 975 checks, 3 official lists, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

cinephage (#24)
klaus78 (#46)
mjf314 (#73)
Mysterious Dude (#42)
Smoover (#63)

#236 (#new) Omoide no Mânî AKA When Marnie Was There (2014, James Simone, Hiromasa Yonebayashi) 145.64 points, 1981 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

6 votersShow

albajos (#63)
beavis (#12)
hurluberlu (unranked>45)
Perception de Ambiguity (#625)
Smoover (#54)
TraverseTown (#53)

[joachimt]

#235 (#new) L'horloge magique ou La petite fille qui voulait être princesse (1928, Wladyslaw Starewicz) 147.1 points, 25 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

Mysterious Dude (#60)
Opio (#2)
Perception de Ambiguity (#934)
St. Gloede (#44)

#234 (-59, #175) The Cat Came Back AKA Le chat colla (1988, Cordell Barker) 147.91 points, 2487 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

1SO (#86)
mathiasa (#185)
maxwelldeux (#12)
mightysparks (#91)
zuma (#22)

#233 (#new) FernGully: The Last Rainforest (1992, Bill Kroyer) 148.15 points, 6307 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

Coryn (#21)
Fergenaprido (#58)
mightysparks (#14)
zzzorf (#201)

[joachimt]

A random stat I pulled out of the spreadsheet:

The number of movies each voter has on the Ain't Nobody's Blues But My Own list.
Perception de Ambiguity (492)
zzzorf (124)
Fergenaprido (66)
albajos (44)
Caracortada (42)
Mysterious Dude (39)
mathiasa (33)
bal3x (31)
gromit82 (31)
mjf314 (28)
Onderhond (21)
Carmel1379 (20)
Cocoa (18)
Opio (18)
wasabi (18)
hurluberlu (17)
mightysparks (16)
rnilsson19 (15)
Panunzio (10)
russa03 (10)
cinephage (9)
TaverseTown (9)
beasterne (8)
tommy_leazaq (8)
XxXApathy420XxX (8)
jiraffejustin (7)
jeff_v (6)
1SO (5)
Gordon_Gekko (5)
jvv (5)
Lonewolf2003 (5)
TajSamKojiJesam (5)
Coryn (4)
Teproc (4)
GruesomeTwosome (3)
max-scl (3)
Smoover (3)
sol (3)
Traveller (3)
zuma (3)
beavis (2)
filmbantha (2)
Mate_cosido (2)
St. Gloede (2)
flaiky (1)
blocho (0)
klaus78 (0)
Lakigigar (0)
maxwelldeux (0)

[joachimt]

#232 (#new) Nekojiru-sô AKA Cat Soup (2001, Tatsuo Satô) 150.5 points, 820 checks, 2 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

Carmel1379 (#202)
Perception de Ambiguity (#365)
rnilsson19 (#24)
wasabi (#2)

#231 (#new) Steklyannaya garmonika AKA The Glass Harmonica (1968, Andrey Khrzhanovskiy) 150.79 points, 91 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

jiraffejustin (#24)
Mysterious Dude (#6)
russa03 (#81)

#230 (#new) Ma vie de Courgette AKA My Life as a Zucchini (2016, Claude Barras) 150.84 points, 1083 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

7 votersShow

Carmel1379 (#159)
cinephage (#67)
klaus78 (#29)
Smoover (#58)
Teproc (#31)
TraverseTown (#59)
zzzorf (#123)

[joachimt]

#229 (#new) Ginga-tetsudô no yoru AKA Kenji Miyazawa's Night on the Galactic Express (1985, Gisaburô Sugii, Arlen Tarlofsky) 151.81 points, 277 checks, 2 official lists, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

beavis (#28)
mjf314 (#46)
rnilsson19 (#11)

#228 (#new) The Congress (2013, Ari Folman) 154.05 points, 960 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

beavis (#29)
cinephage (#62)
filmbantha (#23)
hurluberlu (unranked>45)
TraverseTown (#47)

#227 (#new) Team America: World Police (2004, Trey Parker) 154.5 points, 23612 checks, 5 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

maxwelldeux (#20)
Panunzio (#104)
Perception de Ambiguity (#132)
zzzorf (#6)

[joachimt]

I'll throw in some random stats now and then.......

There are 74 new titles in the top 250.
23 of those are from 2014 and later (last poll was in 2014).

[joachimt]

#226 (-106, #120) Kiwi! (2006, Dony Permedi) 154.9 points, 6186 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

7 votersShow

Carmel1379 (#50)
jvv (unranked)
Lonewolf2003 (#59)
Mate_cosido (#35)
mightysparks (#52)
Perception de Ambiguity (#156)
wasabi (#99)

#225 (#new) Psiconautas, los niños olvidados AKA Birdboy: The Forgotten Children (2015, Pedro Rivero, Alberto Vázquez) 155.9 points, 109 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

Carmel1379 (#23)
mjf314 (#53)
wasabi (#10)

#224 (-39, #185) Beavis and Butt-Head Do America (1996, Mike de Seve, Yvette Kaplan, Brian Mulroney, Mike Judge) 159.09 points, 9120 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

GruesomeTwosome (#35)
mathiasa (#84)
mightysparks (#4)
Perception de Ambiguity (#67)
zzzorf (#141)

[joachimt]

There are 32 unofficial checks in the top 250.

[Coryn]

Is it possible to see which movies are in my blues list?

[joachimt]

Is it possible to see which movies are in my blues list?

Yes, I'll post such things (upon request) after the countdown. Don't want to spoil too much now.

[Coryn]

Is it possible to see which movies are in my blues list?

Yes, I'll post such things (upon request) after the countdown. Don't want to spoil too much now.

Great !

[joachimt]

#223 (-18, #205) Three Little Pigs (1933, Burt Gillett) 159.11 points, 5771 checks, 2 official lists, (IMDb)

9 votersShow

Caracortada (#19)
Fergenaprido (#209)
flaiky (#75)
Gordon_Gekko (#86)
hurluberlu (unranked>45)
jvv (unranked)
mathiasa (#49)
Panunzio (#119)
Perception de Ambiguity (#215)

#222 (#new) Koto no ha no niwa AKA The Garden of Words (2013, Makoto Shinkai) 160.83 points, 1238 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

7 votersShow

beavis (#27)
GruesomeTwosome (#74)
Onderhond (#47)
Perception de Ambiguity (#175)
St. Gloede (#35)
TraverseTown (#49)
wasabi (#110)

#221 (-79, #142) Cars (2006, John Lasseter, Joe Ranft) 161.78 points, 64148 checks, 3 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

hurluberlu (unranked>45)
Perception de Ambiguity (#588)
tommy_leazaq (#4)
zzzorf (#18)

[joachimt]

One movie from the old top 250 didn't receive a single vote this time:
#220 The Fantastic Flying Books of Mr. Morris Lessmore

[Onderhond]

I think that used to be in the IMDb shorts Top 50. It lost its official check, so that must be it

[sol]

A random stat I pulled out of the spreadsheet:

The number of movies each voter has on the Ain't Nobody's Blues But My Own list.

sol (3)

So I was the only voter for $9.99 and Aachi& Ssipak... and one other.

[sol]

There are 32 unofficial checks in the top 250.

And we've only had 5 Unofficial ones so far... so 27 in the top 220 - or more than 12%. Sounds higher than usual for a genre poll? Don't know.

[Onderhond]

Aachi& Ssipak

I liked that one, but not quite enough to make my favorite list. It's trumped by films like Redline and Dead Leaves imo

[albajos]

There are 32 unofficial checks in the top 250.

And we've only had 5 Unofficial ones so far... so 27 in the top 220 - or more than 12%. Sounds higher than usual for a genre poll? Don't know.

There aren't that many official animated movies in 2+ lists. And the majority of those on one list are shorts. I have seen all in 4+ list, and only needed one challenge to get through them.

Also, the official lists doesn't really welcome newer features like Breadwinner, La tortue rouge and Ma vie de Courgette. They have to get into the 21st Century list, and only 4.2% of that list is animated

[Onderhond]

Animation is definitely one of those areas (wouldn't call it a "genre") where canon has a lesser grip. It's only with the addition of the Paste Anime Top 100 that Japanese animation had a decent representative on ICM, for other more "adult" animation films there's almost no way to get official status.

[joachimt]

#220 (+9, #229) A Chairy Tale (1957, Norman McLaren, Claude Jutra) 165 points, 454 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

bal3x (#10)
GruesomeTwosome (#30)
mightysparks (#32)

#219 (#new) Shaun the Sheep Movie (2015, Mark Burton, Richard Starzak) 165.06 points, 2071 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

gromit82 (unranked>25)
jvv (unranked)
max-scl (#5)
Smoover (#53)

#218 (#new) Kono sekai no katasumi ni AKA In This Corner of the World (2016, Sunao Katabuchi) 166.08 points, 302 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

Mate_cosido (#34)
mjf314 (#43)
Onderhond (#35)
Smoover (#22)

[joachimt]

This is the biggest drop from a movie that was in the top 250 previously, but still received at least one vote this time.



#1683 (-1436, #247) Coal Black and de Sebben Dwarfs (1943, Robert Clampett) 0 points, checks, official lists, (IMDb)

1 votersShow

Perception de Ambiguity (#398)

0 points actually means 0.001658226 to be precise.

[Onderhond]

@joachimt: wrong link on Coal Black. It links back to this topic

[joachimt]

@joachimt: wrong link on Coal Black. It links back to this topic

I know. Everything below 250 has no iCM-link in my spreadsheet, because I can't add the "all votes" list to iCM yet, because PdA voted for some movies again which are not on iCM yet.

[joachimt]

Animation is definitely one of those areas (wouldn't call it a "genre") where canon has a lesser grip. It's only with the addition of the Paste Anime Top 100 that Japanese animation had a decent representative on ICM, for other more "adult" animation films there's almost no way to get official status.

There are currently 697 official checks with genre "animation" on iCM. Not that many indeed considering the 15k (how many is it at the moment, Tim?) official checks there are.

[Onderhond]

There are currently 697 official checks with genre "animation" on iCM.

Can you easily determine the ratio shorts/features (30 or 45 mins as divider, I don't really mind)?

[joachimt]

There are currently 697 official checks with genre "animation" on iCM.

Can you easily determine the ratio shorts/features (30 or 45 mins as divider, I don't really mind)?

No, not easily.

[joachimt]

#217 (#new) Da nao tian gong AKA The Monkey King (1963, Wan Laiming) 166.62 points, 93 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

hurluberlu (#25)
Mate_cosido (#32)
mjf314 (#35)
rnilsson19 (#40)

#216 (#new) The Road to El Dorado (2000, Don Paul, Bibo Bergeron, Jeffrey Katzenberg) 168.62 points, 9904 checks, 0 official lists, (IMDb)

3 votersShow

beasterne (#8)
Cocoa (#15)
Panunzio (#62)

#215 (-78, #137) King-Size Canary (1947, Tex Avery) 168.69 points, 2950 checks, 4 official lists, (IMDb)

7 votersShow

albajos (#79)
cinephage (#96)
Gordon_Gekko (#44)
jiraffejustin (#9)
mathiasa (#191)
maxwelldeux (#35)
Perception de Ambiguity (#262)

[joachimt]

29 titles in the top 250 have less than 400 checks.
16 have less than 200.
9 have less than 100.
4 have less than 50.
1 has less than 10 (but even managed to get inside the top 200).

[TraverseTown]

A random stat I pulled out of the spreadsheet:

The number of movies each voter has on the Ain't Nobody's Blues But My Own list.

sol (3)

So I was the only voter for $9.99 and Aachi& Ssipak... and one other.

No, I voted for Aachi & Ssipak too.

[joachimt]

#214 (-46, #168) Jídlo AKA Food (1993, Jan Svankmajer) 169.97 points, 1024 checks, 2 official lists, (IMDb)

5 votersShow

GruesomeTwosome (#33)
hurluberlu (#26)
jeff_v (#52)
Perception de Ambiguity (#239)
sol (#23)

#213 (#new) Brave (2012, Steve Purcell, Mark Andrews, Brenda Chapman) 170.82 points, 29238 checks, 1 official list, (IMDb)

9 votersShow

beasterne (#72)
Caracortada (#108)
Fergenaprido (#34)
gromit82 (unranked>25)
jeff_v (#49)
Lakigigar (#21)
mathiasa (#134)
Panunzio (#86)
zzzorf (#145)

#212 (#new) Prezít svuj zivot (teorie a praxe) AKA Surviving Life (Theory and Practice) (2010, Jan Svankmajer) 171.24 points, 188 checks, 2 official lists, (IMDb)

4 votersShow

mjf314 (#61)
Smoover (#76)
sol (#8)
XxXApathy420XxX (#21)

[joachimt]

A random stat I pulled out of the spreadsheet:

The number of movies each voter has on the Ain't Nobody's Blues But My Own list.

sol (3)

So I was the only voter for $9.99 and Aachi& Ssipak... and one other.

No, I voted for Aachi & Ssipak too.

#424 (#new) Aachi & Ssipak (2006, Jo Beom-jin) 74.74 points, checks, official lists, (IMDb)

2 votersShow

sol (#43)
TraverseTown (#31)

[joachimt]

By calculating the ratio "old rank / new rank" the relatively biggest jump up within the top 250 has a ratio of 8.33. The relatively biggest fall down within the top 250 has a ratio of 0.2.