Welcome to the ICM Forum. If you have an account but have trouble logging in, or have other questions, see THIS THREAD.
NOTE: Board emails should be working again. Information on forum upgrade and style issues.
Podcast: Talking Images (Episode 22 released November 17th * EXCLUSIVE * We Are Mentioned in a Book!!! Interview with Mary Guillermin on Rapture, JG & More)
Polls: Coming of Age (Results), DtC - Ratings (Results), 1933 (May 12th), 1970s (May 29th)
Challenges: Japan, Mystery/Thriller, Western
Film of the Week: La donna del lago, June nominations (May 28th)

Doubling the Canon 2021 Update - Results!

500<400, Favourite 1001 movies, Doubling the Canon, Film World Cup and many other votes
Post Reply
User avatar
Fergenaprido
Donator
Posts: 5482
Joined: June 3rd, 2014, 6:00 am
Location: Canada
Contact:

#481

Post by Fergenaprido »

Angel Glez wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 6:13 pm
Fergenaprido wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 6:01 pm What's the cutoff for holdovers? Anything 3.54+ with less than 8 votes? Or is there a sliding scale like previous years?
I have taken the same as always. Frankly, I have not looked closely at this issue.
So holdovers are based on the Arithmetic Mean, not the Weighted Average, correct?
🧚‍♂️🦫
User avatar
Ebbywebby
Posts: 4076
Joined: September 10th, 2012, 6:00 am
Location: Orange County, CA
Contact:

#482

Post by Ebbywebby »

Angel Glez wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 3:18 pm
blocho wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 2:22 pm How is the weighted average calculated? And what does the recycle symbol mean? And which determines what makes the cut, the weighted average or the mean?
1. Bayesian formula IMDb style.
W = R ⋅ v + C ⋅ m v + m {\displaystyle W={\frac {\ R\cdot v+C\cdot m\ }{v+m}}}
{\displaystyle W={\frac {\ R\cdot v+C\cdot m\ }{v+m}}}
where:

W {\displaystyle W\ } W\ = weighted rating
R {\displaystyle R\ } R\ = average for the movie as a number from 1 to 10 (mean) = (Rating)
v {\displaystyle v\ } v\ = number of votes for the movie = (votes)
m {\displaystyle m\ } m\ = minimum votes required to be listed in the Top 250 (currently 25,000)
C {\displaystyle C\ } C\ = the mean vote across the whole report (currently 7.0)


Seems like there are some formatting glitches in the above, no? Can someone make this clearer?
matthewscott8
Donator
Posts: 2096
Joined: May 13th, 2015, 6:00 am
Contact:

#483

Post by matthewscott8 »

St. Gloede wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 11:18 am
hurluberlu wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 9:37 am
Angel Glez wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 9:31 am
À l'ombre de la canaille bleue1986Pierre Clémenti:imdb:hurluberlu3,73153,59Image
Finally !!! :circle:
:circle: :circle: :circle:
I absolutely love this film but have to admit it's only in because the rules changed and it also looks like a clementi detractor didnt vote this year. I remember him posting on a forum in yesteryear something like, "can we all agree Clementi is trash" but in a much more scathing way.
User avatar
Angel Glez
Posts: 2360
Joined: April 2nd, 2012, 6:00 am
Location: Spain
Contact:

#484

Post by Angel Glez »

TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
Crónica de un niño solo1965Leonardo Favio:imdb:revote3,17183,22
Csend és kiáltás1968Miklós Jancsó:imdb:revote3,86213,71Image
Da nao tian gong1963Wan Laiming, Cheng Tang:imdb:revote3,13153,20
Daimajin ikaru1966Kenji Misumi:imdb:frbrown2,7173,04
Daleká cesta1950Alfréd Radok:imdb:revote4,00123,73Image
Dalkomhan insaeng2005Jee-woon Kim:imdb:filmbantha2,91342,99
Dance Me to My Song1998Rolf de Heer:imdb:72aicm4,5063,83:repeat:
Day Night Day Night2006Julia Loktev:imdb:TSPDT3,4493,39
Days of Waiting1991Steven Okazaki:imdb:Nathan Treadway3,5043,39
De cierta manera1977Sara Gómez:imdb:connordenney2,79192,95
De grands événements et des gens ordinaires1979Raoul Ruiz:imdb:connordenney3,8673,58
De jurk1996Alex van Warmerdam:imdb:sol3,45113,40
De komst van Joachim Stiller1976Harry Kümel:imdb:frbrown3,80103,59Image
Dead End Drive-In1986Brian Trenchard-Smith:imdb:dirty_score2,09112,61
Deanimated2002Martin Arnold:imdb:Carmel13793,6793,51
Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father2008Kurt Kuenne:imdb:monclivie2,89272,99
Deformer2000Mike Mills:imdb:Mauries2,8053,13
Delta2008Kornél Mundruczó:imdb:pitchorneirda2,86143,03
Den brysomme mannen2006Jens Lien:imdb:beavis3,11193,17
Den skyldige2018Gustav Möller:imdb:Fergenaprido3,64223,55Image
Der Engel mit dem Saitenspiel1944Heinz Rühmann:imdb:Dolwphin4,0053,59
Der Fall Gleiwitz1961Gerhard Klein:imdb:revote4,70104,09Image
Der Mörder Dimitri Karamasoff1931Fyodor Otsep, Erich Engel:imdb:revote3,80103,59Image
Der Postmeister1940Gustav Ucicky:imdb:MovieGuide13,91113,67Image
Der verzauberte Tag1944Peter Pewas:imdb:Dolwphin4,4493,92Image
Destry Rides Again1939George Marshall:imdb:revote3,45443,44
Det speglar i mitt öga1992Nina Hedenius:imdb:greennui3,70103,54
Deutschland bleiche Mutter1980Helma Sanders-Brahms:imdb:revote3,23133,27
Diabel1972Andrzej Zulawski:imdb:zomgmouse3,48313,45
Dialogue with a Woman Departed1980Leo Hurwitz:imdb:perceval5,1474,18:repeat:
Die andere Seite1931Heinz Paul:imdb:jdidaco5,2054,05:repeat:
Die Brücke1959Bernhard Wicki:imdb:revote4,19474,07Image
Die freudlose Gasse1925Georg Wilhelm Pabst:imdb:revote3,80353,71Image
Die Geschichte vom weinenden Kamel2003Byambasuren Davaa, Luigi Falorni:imdb:revote3,11193,17
Die goldene Stadt1942Veit Harlan:imdb:jdidaco4,5063,83:repeat:
Die Patriotin1979Alexander Kluge:imdb:Wille3,4493,39
Dieu sait quoi1994Jean-Daniel Pollet:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity4,6794,04Image
Divino Amor2019Gabriel Mascaro:imdb:Fergenaprido1,7172,58
Dni zatmeniya1988Aleksandr Sokurov:imdb:lineuphere2,93293,02
Døden er et kjærtegn1949Edith Carlmar:imdb:72aicm3,72183,60Image
Dominion2018Chris Delforce:imdb:Jimi Antiloop4,3333,60
Don Cesare di Bazan1942Riccardo Freda:imdb:Hawk4,7543,80:repeat:
Donovan's Reef1963John Ford:imdb:revote3,45203,42
Dood water1934Gerard Rutten:imdb:twodeadmagpies5,0023,66
Dr. Jack1922Fred C. Newmeyer, Sam Taylor:imdb:sol3,19163,24
Drive a Crooked Road1954Richard Quine:imdb:revote3,50203,45
Drowning by Numbers1988Peter Greenaway:imdb:Ebbywebby3,54373,50
Du skal ære din hustru1925Carl Theodor Dreyer:imdb:connordenney3,03363,08
Duct Tape Forever2002Eric Till:imdb:beasterne3,5023,36
Duminica la ora 61966Lucian Pintilie:imdb:Wille4,2293,80Image
Duo sang1994Nien-Jen Wu:imdb:Melvelet3,14223,19
Dvadtsat dney bez voyny1977Aleksey German:imdb:revote3,33153,33
Dvadtsat shest komissarov1932Nikoloz Shengelaia:imdb:prodigalgodson3,8053,51
Dzhamilya1969Irina Poplavskaya, Sergei Yutkevich:imdb:revote3,93153,72Image
Dzien swira2002Marek Koterski:imdb:jal902,8993,10
Dzma2014Téona Grenade, Thierry Grenade:imdb:Fergenaprido5,0013,52
Edge of Darkness1985tvMiniSeries:imdb:holdover3,4053,36
Eika Katappa1969Werner Schroeter:imdb:prodigalgodson5,4054,13:repeat:
El auge del humano2016Eduardo Williams:imdb:beavis3,3393,33
El cant dels ocells2008Albert Serra:imdb:matthewscott83,53153,46
El cielo gira2004Mercedes Álvarez:imdb:TSPDT4,0093,68Image
El día de la bestia1995Álex de la Iglesia:imdb:flavo50003,34293,34
El haram1965Henry Barakat:imdb:revote3,54133,46
El lugar más pequeño2011Tatiana Huezo:imdb:rnilsson194,8363,97:repeat:
El otro Francisco1974Sergio Giral:imdb:joachimt2,62132,89
El silencio de otros2018Robert Bahar, Almudena Carracedo:imdb:blocho4,0033,51
El viaje a ninguna parte1986Fernando Fernán Gómez:imdb:jal902,8673,11
Elena2012Petra Costa:imdb:72aicm3,8883,60Image
Ema2019Pablo Larraín:imdb:matthewscott82,94173,07
Empty Metal2018Bayley Sweitzer, Adam Khalil:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity6,0013,63
En la selva no hay estrellas1967Armando Robles Godoy:imdb:sortile9io4,6794,04Image
Enough Said2013Nicole Holofcener:imdb:TSPDT2,75202,92
Era notte a Roma1960Roberto Rossellini:imdb:revote4,38133,98Image
Estiu 19932017Carla Simón:imdb:St. Gloede3,37303,36
Et Resurrectus Est1994R. Bruce Elder:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity5,0074,11:repeat:
Exam Conditions1992Jon Scoffield:imdb:dirty_score5,0033,79
Exil Shanghai1997Ulrike Ottinger:imdb:longsilence5,0033,79
Eye of God1997Tim Blake Nelson:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac884,5023,56
Fai seung dat yin1998Tat-Chi Yau:imdb:cinephage3,5083,42
Falkens öga1998Mikael Kristersson:imdb:rnilsson194,4053,74:repeat:
Fando y Lis1968Alejandro Jodorowsky:imdb:Ebbywebby3,05203,13
Far and Away1992Ron Howard:imdb:dirty_score1,00111,98
Faraon1966Jerzy Kawalerowicz:imdb:revote4,06183,83Image
Faryad moorcheha2006Mohsen Makhmalbaf:imdb:Jimi Antiloop4,2973,78:repeat:
Fata Morgana2013Peter Schreiner:imdb:longsilence5,0043,89:repeat:
Faust Sonnengesang2011Werner Fritsch:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity2,8053,13
Fearless1993Peter Weir:imdb:Jimi Antiloop3,04233,12
Feng ai2013Bing Wang:imdb:revote3,77133,60Image
Feu Mathias Pascal1926Marcel L'Herbier:imdb:revote3,67183,56Image
Fiamma che non si spegne1949Vittorio Cottafavi:imdb:Hawk4,5063,83:repeat:
Filantropica2002Nae Caranfil:imdb:toromash3,23223,25
Film Film Film1968Fyodor Khitruk:imdb:flip2,97293,04
Films to Break Projectors2017Tim Grabham:imdb:Hunziker1,93142,44
Final Cut: Hölgyeim és uraim2012György Pálfi:imdb:filmbantha3,44343,42
First Man2018Damien Chazelle:imdb:Teproc2,89362,97
Five Star Final1931Mervyn LeRoy:imdb:cinephage3,07143,17
Flandres2006Bruno Dumont:imdb:TSPDT2,50162,78
Flatlife2004Jonas Geirnaert:imdb:revote2,64252,81
For All Mankind1989Al Reinert:imdb:beasterne3,40303,39
Fountain of Dreams1984Jordan Belson:imdb:Dolwphin3,57233,50
matthewscott8
Donator
Posts: 2096
Joined: May 13th, 2015, 6:00 am
Contact:

#485

Post by matthewscott8 »

matthewscott8 wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 8:10 pm
St. Gloede wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 11:18 am
hurluberlu wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 9:37 am

Finally !!! :circle:
:circle: :circle: :circle:
I absolutely love this film but have to admit it's only in because the rules changed and it also looks like a clementi detractor didnt vote this year. I remember him posting on a forum in yesteryear something like, "can we all agree Clementi is trash" but in a much more scathing way.
Also I note the rating has gone down from last year when I nominated, same number of votes. 3.86 from 15 votes last year, so an example perhaps of how the change in evaluation criteria has changed the DtC world.
User avatar
sol
Donator
Posts: 11438
Joined: February 3rd, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Perth, WA, Australia
Contact:

#486

Post by sol »

Angel Glez wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 3:39 pm
Be My Wife1921Max Linder:imdb:sol3,7893,57Image
Brothers' Nest2018Clayton Jacobson:imdb:sol4,0093,68Image
Buchanan Rides Alone1958Budd Boetticher:imdb:sol3,69263,61Image
:satstunned:

That's never happened before. Even if none of my other nominees make it (many have already been eliminated), this is a record-best performance for me.

Oh, and thanks, Roger. I'm disappointed about Cash on Demand too. Easily the best film that I saw for the DTC Challenge this year. Hopefully it will have more success in the next 500<400 update.
Former IMDb message boards user // iCM | IMDb | Letterboxd | My top 750 films // Long live the new flesh!
Image Image Image
User avatar
72aicm
Donator
Posts: 3593
Joined: November 13th, 2016, 7:00 am
Contact:

#487

Post by 72aicm »

Two that made it and two holdovers out of four noms so far for me. :pleasing:
User avatar
Angel Glez
Posts: 2360
Joined: April 2nd, 2012, 6:00 am
Location: Spain
Contact:

#488

Post by Angel Glez »

TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
Foxtrot2017Samuel Maoz:imdb:Teproc3,21193,25
Frágil Como o Mundo2001Rita Azevedo Gomes:imdb:Ivan07163,69163,57Image
Frank2014Lenny Abrahamson:imdb:TSPDT2,36222,62
Frankenstein Created Woman1967Terence Fisher:imdb:Angel Glez2,91223,02
From Hell to Texas1958Henry Hathaway:imdb:revote3,67183,56Image
From the Four Corners1942Anthony Havelock-Allan:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac881,6762,62
Fuefukigawa1960Keisuke Kinoshita:imdb:revote3,85133,65Image
Fuori dal giorno1983Paolo Bologna:imdb:insomnius4,5043,72
Gaebyeok1991Kwon-taek Im:imdb:karl3,0043,22
Gambling, Gods and LSD2002Peter Mettler:imdb:prodigalgodson3,67123,53
Gánh Xiêc Rong1988Linh Viet:imdb:jal903,4493,39
Gemide1998Serdar Akar:imdb:Angel Glez2,2582,79
Georgy Girl1966Silvio Narizzano:imdb:Hunziker2,75122,98
Geschichtsunterricht1972Danièle Huillet, Jean-Marie Straub:imdb:revote3,28183,29
Geung see sin sang1985Ricky Lau:imdb:revote3,60303,54Image
Gheisar1969Masud Kimiai:imdb:revote2,8993,10
Ghostwatch1992Lesley Manning:imdb:flavo50003,68223,59Image
Girl Walk: All Day2011Jacob Krupnick:imdb:revote3,71313,63Image
Girlfight2000Karyn Kusama:imdb:TSPDT2,67152,90
Gishiki1971Nagisa Ôshima:imdb:revote3,92263,78Image
Give Us This Day1949Edward Dmytryk:imdb:flavo50003,2293,27
Glas1958Bert Haanstra:imdb:joachimt3,28433,29
Glória1999Manuela Viegas:imdb:Wille4,7543,80:repeat:
Go do gaai bei1997Ringo Lam:imdb:cinephage3,5773,44
Gohiki no shinshi1966Hideo Gosha:imdb:MovieGuide14,00103,70Image
Gondola1987Chisho Itoh:imdb:longsilence6,0023,86:repeat:
Gongdong gyeongbi guyeok JSA2000Chan-wook Park:imdb:toromash3,24423,25
Go-yang-i-leul boo-tak-hae2001Jae-eun Jeong:imdb:Carmel13793,50243,46
Grauzone1979Fredi M. Murer:imdb:jdidaco4,6733,69
Gravity2006Nicolas Provost:imdb:Hunziker2,70202,88
Great Expectations1998Alfonso Cuarón:imdb:dirty_score1,69132,32
Green for Danger1946Sidney Gilliat:imdb:George Eastman3,43303,41
Grzeli nateli dgeebi2013Nana Ekvtimishvili, Simon Groß:imdb:zzzorf2,65172,87
Gueule d'amour1937Jean Grémillon:imdb:revote3,57143,48
Gun Hill Road2011Rashaad Ernesto Green:imdb:Daviddoes6,0023,86:repeat:
Gunhamdo2017Seung-wan Ryoo:imdb:cinephage3,0053,20
Gunman's Walk1958Phil Karlson:imdb:revote4,44184,10Image
Guns1980Robert Kramer:imdb:karldaniel5,0033,79
Gwen, le livre de sable1985Jean-François Laguionie:imdb:matthewscott83,40153,38
H-8...1958Nikola Tanhofer:imdb:Gordon_Gekko3,42363,40
Hadashi no Gen1983Mori Masaki:imdb:revote3,91233,76Image
Hævnens Nat1916Benjamin Christensen:imdb:zzzorf3,40103,37
Hai tan de yi tian1983Edward Yang:imdb:revote3,88243,74Image
Haibane Renmei2002tvMiniSeries:imdb:mjf3143,3363,33
Hail the Conquering Hero1944Preston Sturges:imdb:revote3,74313,66Image
Hair High2004Bill Plympton:imdb:sol3,4373,38
Hamoun1990Dariush Mehrjui:imdb:RolandKirkSunglasses2,20102,70
Hanare goze Orin1977Masahiro Shinoda:imdb:cinephage3,40103,37
Händelse vid bank2010Ruben Östlund:imdb:AB5372,75162,94
Hangover Square1945John Brahm:imdb:cinephage3,71343,63Image
Happy Here and Now2002Michael Almereyda:imdb:MrCarmady2,5043,05
Harry & Son1984Paul Newman:imdb:jal903,0063,19
Harvie Krumpet2003Adam Elliot:imdb:George Eastman3,18343,21
Hasta el viento tiene miedo1968Carlos Enrique Taboada:imdb:frbrown2,94163,07
Hat Wolff von Amerongen Konkursdelikte begangen?2004Gerhard Benedikt Friedl:imdb:TSPDT4,7584,04Image
Hatsukoi: Jigoku-hen1968Susumu Hani:imdb:revote4,21193,95Image
Hausu1977Nobuhiko Ôbayashi:imdb:Panunzio3,43563,42
Haze2005Shin'ya Tsukamoto:imdb:flavo50003,09233,15
Head Over Heels1979Joan Micklin Silver:imdb:greennui3,79143,62Image
Heimkehr1928Joe May:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac883,80103,59Image
Hello, Sister!1933Raoul Walsh, Erich von Stroheim, Alfred L. Werker, Alan Crosland:imdb:cayado-coro3,3363,33
Hells Angels on Wheels1967Richard Rush:imdb:Daviddoes2,2972,84
Her Smell2018Alex Ross Perry:imdb:Teproc3,08123,18
Heroes for Sale1933William A. Wellman:imdb:revote4,06163,82Image
Herutâ sukerutâ2012Mika Ninagawa:imdb:Onderhond2,43142,76
Hets1944Alf Sjöberg:imdb:Dolwphin3,44343,42
Heung Gong jai jo1997Fruit Chan:imdb:revote3,64223,55Image
High Hopes1988Mike Leigh:imdb:john ryan3,23223,25
Hjertestart2017Arild Andresen:imdb:albajos5,0023,66
Hobson's Choice1954David Lean:imdb:revote3,25323,27
Höhenfeuer1985Fredi M. Murer:imdb:Melvelet3,75243,65Image
Hôhokekyo tonari no Yamada-kun1999Isao Takahata:imdb:Teproc3,50243,46
Holiday Inn1942Robert Allen, Mark Sandrich:imdb:Umbugbene2,44162,74
Hollywood Story1951William Castle:imdb:frbrown2,91113,09
Home2016Fien Troch:imdb:Lakigigar4,0073,64:repeat:
Hot Gimmick: Girl Meets Boy2019Yûki Yamato:imdb:Onderhond3,3333,33
Housekeeping1987Bill Forsyth:imdb:toromash3,48253,44
How the Grinch Stole Christmas!1966Ben Washam, Chuck Jones:imdb:beasterne3,19373,21
How to Live With Regret2018John Wilson:imdb:beasterne3,2053,28
How to Survive a Plague2012David France:imdb:TSPDT3,1473,24
Howards End1992James Ivory:imdb:Silga3,11373,15
Hringurinn1985Friðrik Þór Friðriksson:imdb:Sy94,08133,79Image
Hundstage2001Ulrich Seidl:imdb:Carmel13792,63242,80
Hunt for the Wilderpeople2016Taika Waititi:imdb:monclivie3,49353,46
Huo shan qing xue1932Yu Sun:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac884,7543,80:repeat:
Hustlers2019Lorene Scafaria:imdb:TSPDT1,89182,33
Hwal2005Kim Ki-duk:imdb:Lakigigar3,16193,21
I bambini ci guardano1944Vittorio De Sica:imdb:cayado-coro3,23223,25
I Confess1953Alfred Hitchcock:imdb:George Eastman2,98443,03
I Do Not Know What It Is I Am Like1986Bill Viola:imdb:jdidaco4,45113,98Image
I earini synaxis ton agrofylakon1999Dimos Avdeliodis:imdb:longsilence4,5043,72
I Love Melvin1953Don Weis:imdb:Lobo López3,4493,39
I topi grigi1918Emilio Ghione:imdb:karldaniel5,0023,66
I, Tonya2017Craig Gillespie:imdb:TSPDT3,20353,22
I'd Climb the Highest Mountain1951Henry King:imdb:Hawk3,4373,38
Igra ljubavi1967Vladimir Momčilović:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac882,8673,11
Ijaazat1987Gulzar:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac884,6733,69
Il cammino della speranza1950Pietro Germi:imdb:revote3,75123,58Image
Il Cristo proibito1951Curzio Malaparte:imdb:cayado-coro4,1383,73Image
Il deserto dei tartari1976Valerio Zurlini:imdb:hurluberlu4,06173,83Image
User avatar
sol
Donator
Posts: 11438
Joined: February 3rd, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Perth, WA, Australia
Contact:

#489

Post by sol »

Hooray for I Do Not Know What It Is I Am Like finally making it. :party:

And shame on nobody other than Dulce and myself checking out Gun Hill Road. :( At least it will be carried over for next year.

Biggest WTF of this bunch for me: Hat Wolff von Amerongen Konkursdelikte begangen? makes the cut. :mellow: I probably should have voted this lower, but I mostly just feel like I missed the point. Still, I'm surprised that a film as "difficult" as this has such strong support.
Former IMDb message boards user // iCM | IMDb | Letterboxd | My top 750 films // Long live the new flesh!
Image Image Image
User avatar
Melvelet
Posts: 2518
Joined: March 29th, 2013, 6:00 am
Location: Berlin, Germany
Contact:

#490

Post by Melvelet »

matthewscott8 wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 11:14 pm
matthewscott8 wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 8:10 pm
St. Gloede wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 11:18 am

:circle: :circle: :circle:
I absolutely love this film but have to admit it's only in because the rules changed and it also looks like a clementi detractor didnt vote this year. I remember him posting on a forum in yesteryear something like, "can we all agree Clementi is trash" but in a much more scathing way.
Also I note the rating has gone down from last year when I nominated, same number of votes. 3.86 from 15 votes last year, so an example perhaps of how the change in evaluation criteria has changed the DtC world.
Previously the lowest vote would have been removed (2 votes for 20+ votes, 3 for 30+ votes, etc.) so the AM of all scores appears lower than it would have been in previous years. Still it's quite interesting that it doesn't take that many votes for a film to get in with an AM of less than 3.7 now. Probably it's easier to get in this year because of allthe TSPDT 1001-2000 movies that fell out. I'm curious about how many movies from previous nomination rounds made the list now
Current recommendation: Mandala (1981)


ImageImage


Current focus: Doubling the Canon nominees, Japan, South Korea

Last.fm | RYM
User avatar
72aicm
Donator
Posts: 3593
Joined: November 13th, 2016, 7:00 am
Contact:

#491

Post by 72aicm »

Hringurinn finally gets official. Not enough votes last year, and thirteen now. What happened?

13 votes and 14 checks. That’s impressive.
Last edited by 72aicm on May 3rd, 2021, 1:43 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Onderhond
Posts: 6849
Joined: December 23rd, 2012, 7:00 am
Contact:

#492

Post by Onderhond »

01. 2,76 - Herutâ sukerutâ
02. 3,33 - Hot Gimmick: Girl Meets Boy

Hot Gimmick looks promising, until you realize it only got 3 votes :D
User avatar
sortile9io
Posts: 3288
Joined: January 23rd, 2013, 7:00 am
Contact:

#493

Post by sortile9io »

Angel Glez wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 10:11 pm
TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
En la selva no hay estrellas1967Armando Robles Godoy:imdb:sortile9io4,6794,04Image
A holdover from last year turned into a new official check thanks to the bonus game in the nominees challenge. Thanks sol and Melvelet for watching it!
User avatar
jal90
Posts: 134
Joined: May 19th, 2019, 1:39 pm
Contact:

#494

Post by jal90 »

I completely forgot to vote, so very glad that Frágil como o mundo made it this year. None of mine so far, but not complaining, I didn't even try to promote them.
User avatar
sol
Donator
Posts: 11438
Joined: February 3rd, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Perth, WA, Australia
Contact:

#495

Post by sol »

sortile9io wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 12:12 pm
Angel Glez wrote: May 2nd, 2021, 10:11 pm
TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
En la selva no hay estrellas1967Armando Robles Godoy:imdb:sortile9io4,6794,04Image
A holdover from last year turned into a new official check thanks to the bonus game in the nominees challenge. Thanks sol and Melvelet for watching it!
Hey, looks like I did something useful this year. :)
Former IMDb message boards user // iCM | IMDb | Letterboxd | My top 750 films // Long live the new flesh!
Image Image Image
User avatar
Angel Glez
Posts: 2360
Joined: April 2nd, 2012, 6:00 am
Location: Spain
Contact:

#496

Post by Angel Glez »

TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
Il dono2003Michelangelo Frammartino:imdb:Mothravka3,8363,55
Il generale Della Rovere1959Roberto Rossellini:imdb:revote3,97303,83Image
Il grande silenzio1968Sergio Corbucci:imdb:revote3,98533,90Image
Il ladro di bambini1992Gianni Amelio:imdb:pitchorneirda3,69163,57Image
Il mulino delle donne di pietra1960Giorgio Ferroni:imdb:frbrown2,89183,02
Il ne suffit pas que Dieu soit avec les pauvres1978Borhane Alaouié, Lotfi Thabet:imdb:longsilence4,6763,90:repeat:
Il peccato2019Andrey Konchalovskiy:imdb:hurluberlu3,7543,47
Ilha das Flores1989Jorge Furtado:imdb:revote3,42553,41
Images1972Robert Altman:imdb:Hunziker3,42333,41
Imburnal2008Sherad Anthony Sanchez:imdb:revote4,45113,98Image
Îmi este indiferent daca în istorie vom intra ca barbari2018Radu Jude:imdb:St. Gloede4,09113,77Image
In jenen Tagen1947Helmut Käutner:imdb:Lobo López3,68193,58Image
Infancia clandestina2011Benjamín Ávila:imdb:72aicm3,0043,22
Inherit the Wind1960Stanley Kramer:imdb:Gordon_Gekko3,33453,33
Institute Benjamenta, or This Dream People Call Human Life1995Weiser Quay, Stephen Quay, Timothy Quay:imdb:revote3,20203,24
Intruder in the Dust1949Clarence Brown:imdb:revote3,68283,60Image
Invisible2005Konstantin Bojanov:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity6,0013,63
Io la conoscevo bene1965Antonio Pietrangeli:imdb:revote3,92373,81Image
Ise Yarar Bir Sey2017Pelin Esmer:imdb:Gordon_Gekko3,6733,42
Iskanderija... lih?1979Youssef Chahine:imdb:revote2,80202,95
Is-slottet1987Per Blom:imdb:hurluberlu3,23223,25
Isten hozta örnagy úr1969Zoltán Fábri:imdb:flip4,0073,64:repeat:
Istoria mias kalpikis liras1955Yorgos Tzavellas:imdb:monclivie4,06183,83Image
It's a Mad Mad Mad Mad World1963Stanley Kramer:imdb:Gordon_Gekko2,29342,49
Izgnanie2007Andrey Zvyagintsev:imdb:revote3,37193,36
J'accuse1919Abel Gance:imdb:cayh4,29284,07Image
Jagdszenen aus Niederbayern1969Peter Fleischmann:imdb:revote3,61313,55Image
Jakten1959Erik Løchen:imdb:St. Gloede3,78273,68Image
Jallikattu2019Lijo Jose Pellissery:imdb:cinephage2,06162,49
Jammin' the Blues1944Gjon Mili:imdb:Dolwphin2,82392,91
Jiabiangou2010Bing Wang:imdb:TSPDT3,7893,57Image
Jibun no ana no nakade1955Tomu Uchida:imdb:lineuphere4,5043,72
Jigureul jikyeora!2003Joon-Hwan Jang:imdb:filmbantha2,73262,87
Jirô monogatari1955Hiroshi Shimizu:imdb:Hawk3,8363,55
Jivaro1954Edward Ludwig:imdb:insomnius3,5693,45
Jonas qui aura 25 ans en l'an 20001976Alain Tanner:imdb:MrCarmady3,24173,27
Judgment at Nuremberg1961Stanley Kramer:imdb:revote3,43463,42
Juliette ou La clef des songes1951Marcel Carné:imdb:Umbugbene3,70103,54
Jûsan-nin no shikaku2010Takashi Miike:imdb:TSPDT2,86352,95
Jusqu'à la garde2017Xavier Legrand:imdb:toromash3,65173,55Image
Kaiba2008tvMiniSeries:imdb:sortile9io4,6763,90:repeat:
Kamera wo tomeruna!2017Shin'ichirô Ueda:imdb:mjf3143,77263,67Image
Kamome shokudô2006Naoko Ogigami:imdb:MrCarmady4,3393,86Image
Kamyu nante shiranai2005Mitsuo Yanagimachi:imdb:john ryan3,30103,31
Kanehsatake: 270 Years of Resistance1993Alanis Obomsawin:imdb:cayh3,60103,48
Kanojo to kare1963Susumu Hani:imdb:revote3,87153,68Image
Kanzashi1941Hiroshi Shimizu:imdb:revote3,89273,76Image
Kanzenna yûgi1958Toshio Masuda:imdb:joachimt3,8363,55
Kapurush1965Satyajit Ray:imdb:revote3,90313,79Image
Karera ga honki de amu toki wa2017Naoko Ogigami:imdb:Fergenaprido3,36113,35
Kárhozat1988Béla Tarr:imdb:revote4,14424,01Image
Katka-bumazhnyy ranet1926Fridrikh Ermler, Eduard Ioganson:imdb:jdidaco4,2973,78:repeat:
Kazdy den odvahu1964Evald Schorm:imdb:MrCarmady3,38163,36
Kaze no naka no kodomo1937Hiroshi Shimizu:imdb:Hawk4,13153,85Image
Kaze no tani no Naushika1984Hayao Miyazaki:imdb:ChrisReynolds3,53533,50
Kazoku gêmu1983Yoshimitsu Morita:imdb:pitchorneirda3,33123,33
Keulraesik2003Jae-young Kwak:imdb:monclivie2,5082,92
Key Largo1948John Huston:imdb:AB5373,88523,81Image
Khake Sar Beh Mohr1977Marva Nabili:imdb:revote3,63163,53
Khayal Gatha1989Kumar Shahani:imdb:insomnius5,0094,21Image
Khesht va Ayeneh1965Ebrahim Golestan:imdb:OldAle13,67243,58Image
Khomreh1992Ebrahim Forouzesh:imdb:72aicm2,8673,11
Kimi no na wa.2016Makoto Shinkai:imdb:TSPDT3,39493,38
Kimssi pyoryugi2009Hae-jun Lee:imdb:monclivie3,44323,42
Kirk Douglas: Before I Forget2009Jeff Kanew:imdb:Nathan Treadway3,0013,29
Kirmes1960Wolfgang Staudte:imdb:lineuphere3,5063,40
Kisapmata1981Mike De Leon:imdb:cayado-coro3,7583,54Image
Kjærlighetens kjøtere1995Hans Petter Moland:imdb:Melvelet2,82222,95
Kler2018Wojciech Smarzowski:imdb:72aicm5,0023,66
Ko to tamo peva1980Slobodan Sijan:imdb:lineuphere3,95213,78Image
Kochegar2010Aleksey Balabanov:imdb:beavis3,7173,51
Kôge - Ichibu: Waremokô no shô1964Keisuke Kinoshita:imdb:Ivan07165,5023,76
Kôge - Nibu: Mitsumata no shô1964Keisuke Kinoshita:imdb:Ivan07165,5023,76
Koibumi1953Kinuyo Tanaka:imdb:revote3,6793,51
Koko-di koko-da2019Johannes Nyholm:imdb:Labraxas2,6053,05
Kokuhakuteki joyûron1971Yoshishige Yoshida:imdb:Ebbywebby3,30103,31
Komisario Palmun erehdys1960Matti Kassila:imdb:zhangalan3,16193,21
Kono hiroi sora no dokoka ni1954Masaki Kobayashi:imdb:RolandKirkSunglasses2,8673,11
Kôshikei1968Nagisa Ôshima:imdb:revote4,00393,89Image
Koto no ha no niwa2013Makoto Shinkai:imdb:AB5373,07283,13
Krakatit1948Otakar Vávra:imdb:OldAle13,67183,56Image
Krysar1986Jirí Barta:imdb:ChrisReynolds3,59413,54Image
Kundskabens træ1981Nils Malmros:imdb:Labraxas3,57143,48
Kurenai no buta1992Hayao Miyazaki:imdb:revote3,34473,34
Kurôn wa kokyô wo mezasu2008Kanji Nakajima:imdb:Onderhond3,3363,33
Kvarteret Korpen1963Bo Widerberg:imdb:lineuphere3,74233,63Image
La ardilla roja1993Julio Medem:imdb:Jimi Antiloop2,86212,99
La belle captive1983Alain Robbe-Grillet:imdb:St. Gloede3,27333,28
La belle équipe1936Julien Duvivier:imdb:revote3,73223,62Image
La bête lumineuse1982Pierre Perrault:imdb:revote3,71213,61Image
La casa Emak Bakia2012Oskar Alegria:imdb:jal903,0013,29
La classe operaia va in paradiso1971Elio Petri:imdb:72aicm3,50183,45
La coquille et le clergyman1928Germaine Dulac:imdb:revote3,64363,58Image
La deuxième nuit2016Eric Pauwels:imdb:St. Gloede4,31133,94Image
La drôlesse1979Jacques Doillon:imdb:revote3,23133,27
La femme de l'aviateur1981Éric Rohmer:imdb:revote4,09433,97Image
La fille du puisatier1940Marcel Pagnol:imdb:Angel Glez4,1383,73Image
La fille inconnue2016Luc Dardenne, Jean-Pierre Dardenne:imdb:Labraxas3,35263,34
La folie Almayer2011Chantal Akerman:imdb:prodigalgodson3,94183,76Image
La glace à trois faces1927Jean Epstein:imdb:hurluberlu3,50323,47
User avatar
Onderhond
Posts: 6849
Joined: December 23rd, 2012, 7:00 am
Contact:

#497

Post by Onderhond »

01. 2,76 - Herutâ sukerutâ
02. 3,33 - Hot Gimmick: Girl Meets Boy
03. 3,33 - Kurôn wa kokyô wo mezasu

Shame, had some hopes for that one. Bit surprised it got to 6 votes though.
User avatar
flavo5000
Posts: 4520
Joined: July 10th, 2014, 6:00 am
Location: Arkansas, USA
Contact:

#498

Post by flavo5000 »

Mine aren't faring super well either.

Clue (1985) 2.74
Córki dancingu a.k.a. The Lure (2015) 3.13
El día de la bestia (1995) 3.34
Ghostwatch (1992) 3.59 :banana:
Give Us This Day a.k.a. Christ in Concrete (1949) 3.27
Haze (2005) 3.15

But hey, at least Ghostwatch made it in.
User avatar
OldAle1
Donator
Posts: 6025
Joined: February 9th, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Dairyland, USA
Contact:

#499

Post by OldAle1 »

Doing OK so far - well, better than OK since I think it's rare for me to have two wins and this is out of only three films so far -

Ángel de fuego 3.25 / 4 / 3.30 - I should have promoted this, it's even on YT subbed. Then again, 3.25 raw including my 6 - probably wouldn't have helped.
Khesht va Ayeneh 3.67 / 25 / 3.58
Krakatit 3.67 / 18 / 3.56

On the other hand Khake Sar Beh Mohr which I think was my submission originally fell off (just barely) on the re-vote. I guess there's a limit to how many depressing pre-revolution Iranian dramas there can be on the list.

Very happy about Act of Violence, Aventurera, Blue Collar, Buchanan Rides Alone, Girl Walk: All Day, and two Marguerite Duras films.

Sad about Go-yang-i-leul boo-tak-hae, the highest-ranked film on my personal favorites list that appeared here, but at least it's on some other lists. Ditto Hamoun.
User avatar
72aicm
Donator
Posts: 3593
Joined: November 13th, 2016, 7:00 am
Contact:

#500

Post by 72aicm »

72aicm wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 5:43 am Two that made it and two holdovers out of four noms so far for me. :pleasing:
0/4 on the next batch. :facepalm:
User avatar
OldAle1
Donator
Posts: 6025
Joined: February 9th, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Dairyland, USA
Contact:

#502

Post by OldAle1 »

RolandKirkSunglasses wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 3:49 pm Chiyari Fuji 3.53 (u)
Yeah that's another one on the bummer list - and I nominated it myself last year and obviously it failed then as well. :(
User avatar
St. Gloede
Moderator
Posts: 12370
Joined: May 6th, 2011, 6:00 am
Contact:

#503

Post by St. Gloede »

Angel Glez wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 2:42 pm
Îmi este indiferent daca în istorie vom intra ca barbari2018Radu Jude:imdb:St. Gloede4,09113,77Image
Jakten1959Erik Løchen:imdb:St. Gloede3,78273,68Image
La belle captive1983Alain Robbe-Grillet:imdb:St. Gloede3,27333,28
La deuxième nuit2016Eric Pauwels:imdb:St. Gloede4,31133,94Image
My strategy of going with my favourite film from each oof the last 4-5 years paid off here. Estiu 1993 (previous result) did not work out well, but here we have I Do Not Care if We Go Down in History as Barbarians and The Second Night blowing up - and they would have performed even stronger without the new weighting system - incredible. Especially looking at Rude's score I'm tempted to push all his recent features next year - as he is likely the best ("younger") filmmaker currently working - and his first exposure on ICM came with his Golden bear win this year.

Also really happy to see Jakten (considered the best Norwegian film of all time by critics) is getting proper community support. Granted, this line of successes is still bittersweet, as the best film I nominated, La Belle Captive, could not make the cut.
User avatar
RogerTheMovieManiac88
Posts: 2012
Joined: February 4th, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Westmeath, Ireland
Contact:

#504

Post by RogerTheMovieManiac88 »

Really happy to see 'Der Postmeister' finally make it in. Such a wonderfully observed little film full of touching detail and humanity!

And 'Den skyldige' as well, along with positive outcomes for the Heinz Paul and the Peter Pewas (two films that I had really hoped to get to last month - next year, I hope!).

OOPS.... I went back and the Pewas actually gets over the line this year. Great stuff!
Last edited by RogerTheMovieManiac88 on May 3rd, 2021, 4:55 pm, edited 2 times in total.
That's all, folks!
User avatar
Torgo
Posts: 2938
Joined: June 30th, 2011, 6:00 am
Location: Germany
Contact:

#505

Post by Torgo »

RogerTheMovieManiac88 wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 4:43 pm And 'Den skyldige' as well
Oh, you're right. Cool. Will become an official check with this DtC update :thumbsup:
User avatar
RogerTheMovieManiac88
Posts: 2012
Joined: February 4th, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Westmeath, Ireland
Contact:

#506

Post by RogerTheMovieManiac88 »

I'm fairly content to see the high score for 'Ijaazat', from the three votes it managed.

Also, it's fantastic to see 'Heimkehr' take a place in the list. Ever so glad to see one of my absolute favourite films do well here! And, 'Loving Blood of the Volcano' retains its holdover status. Nice one!
That's all, folks!
User avatar
Angel Glez
Posts: 2360
Joined: April 2nd, 2012, 6:00 am
Location: Spain
Contact:

#507

Post by Angel Glez »

TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
La gloire de mon père1990Yves Robert:imdb:revote3,2293,27
La grande vadrouille1966Gérard Oury:imdb:revote3,00223,09
La guerre d'un seul homme1982Edgardo Cozarinsky:imdb:revote4,30103,87Image
La guerre est déclarée2011Valérie Donzelli:imdb:cayado-coro4,2053,66
La gueule ouverte1974Maurice Pialat:imdb:revote4,21284,02Image
La leggenda del santo bevitore1988Ermanno Olmi:imdb:pitchorneirda3,83183,68Image
La lengua de las mariposas1999José Luis Cuerda:imdb:dirty_score2,8053,13
La lune dans le caniveau1983Jean-Jacques Beineix:imdb:Umbugbene3,0073,18
La marche de l'empereur2005Luc Jacquet:imdb:TSPDT2,88342,97
La mort en direct1980Bertrand Tavernier:imdb:Ebbywebby2,63242,80
La muerte de un burócrata1966Tomás Gutiérrez Alea:imdb:revote4,23314,04Image
La Noche de Enfrente2012Raoul Ruiz:imdb:TSPDT2,82113,03
La nuit fantastique1942Marcel L'Herbier:imdb:Umbugbene3,82173,67Image
La otra1946Roberto Gavaldón:imdb:revote3,87233,73Image
La parmigiana1963Antonio Pietrangeli:imdb:Ivan07163,6053,43
La planète sauvage1973René Laloux:imdb:revote3,81633,76Image
La poison1951Sacha Guitry:imdb:RolandKirkSunglasses3,50283,46
La prima Angélica1974Carlos Saura:imdb:revote3,18173,23
La tía Tula1964Miguel Picazo:imdb:revote3,8883,60Image
La tortue rouge2016Michael Dudok de Wit:imdb:Lakigigar3,45313,43
La vie à l'envers1964Alain Jessua:imdb:matthewscott84,0083,67Image
La vie nouvelle2002Philippe Grandrieux:imdb:TSPDT3,82173,67Image
La visita1963Antonio Pietrangeli:imdb:72aicm3,6793,51
L'Acadie, l'Acadie1971Pierre Perrault, Michel Brault:imdb:Wille3,7543,47
Ladies in Retirement1941Charles Vidor:imdb:flip3,36143,35
Lady for a Day1933Frank Capra:imdb:revote3,40203,38
Lady Macbeth2016William Oldroyd:imdb:cayh2,89282,99
Lage Raho Munna Bhai2006Rajkumar Hirani:imdb:TSPDT1,5022,96
Laila1929George Schnéevoigt:imdb:Angel Glez3,85133,65Image
L'aîné des Ferchaux1963Jean-Pierre Melville:imdb:AB5372,15202,49
Lakposhtha parvaz mikonand2004Bahman Ghobadi:imdb:TSPDT3,75203,63Image
L'amant double2017François Ozon:imdb:Labraxas2,3392,80
L'ami de mon amie1987Éric Rohmer:imdb:revote4,12423,99Image
L'amour d'une femme1953Jean Grémillon:imdb:cayado-coro4,10103,76Image
Landscape Suicide1987James Benning:imdb:revote3,78233,67Image
L'Ange Amazonien1992Maria Klonaris, Katerina Thomadaki:imdb:karldaniel4,5773,91:repeat:
L'armata Brancaleone1966Mario Monicelli:imdb:RolandKirkSunglasses3,45113,40
Las aguas bajan turbias1952Hugo del Carril:imdb:Angel Glez3,5083,42
Lasermannen2005tvMiniSeries:imdb:Wille4,3333,60
L'assassin habite... au 211942Henri-Georges Clouzot:imdb:George Eastman3,65313,58Image
L'assassinat du Père Noël1941Christian-Jaque:imdb:Umbugbene3,08123,18
Last Cab to Darwin2015Jeremy Sims:imdb:blocho2,82172,99
Last Days in a Lonely Place2007Philip S. Solomon:imdb:prodigalgodson3,25123,28
Laugh, Clown, Laugh1928Herbert Brenon:imdb:Lobo López3,05203,13
Laurence Anyways2012Xavier Dolan:imdb:Panunzio3,50323,47
Le brasier ardent1923Ivan Mozzhukhin:imdb:twodeadmagpies4,21143,89Image
Le château de ma mère1990Yves Robert:imdb:revote3,2973,31
Le cousin Jules1972Dominique Benicheti:imdb:Hawk4,7584,04Image
Le déjeuner sur l'herbe1959Jean Renoir:imdb:revote3,50203,45
Le grand bleu1988Luc Besson:imdb:Silga2,88242,99
Le Horla1966Jean-Daniel Pollet:imdb:prodigalgodson3,60153,51
Le joli mai1963Pierre Lhomme, Chris Marker:imdb:revote3,57213,50
Le monde vivant2003Eugène Green:imdb:toromash3,82173,67Image
Le passé2013Asghar Farhadi:imdb:Lakigigar3,37383,36
Le révélateur1968Philippe Garrel:imdb:revote3,31393,31
Le roi et l'oiseau1980Paul Grimault:imdb:revote3,15273,19
Le roman de Renard1937Wladyslaw Starewicz, Irene Starewicz:imdb:St. Gloede3,18403,20
Le signe du lion1962Éric Rohmer:imdb:OldAle13,60303,54Image
Le stagioni del nostro amore1966Florestano Vancini:imdb:Umbugbene3,8053,51
Le tout nouveau testament2015Jaco Van Dormael:imdb:Carmel13793,04273,10
Leák1981H. Tjut Djalil:imdb:flavo50001,91112,51
Lean on Pete2017Andrew Haigh:imdb:blocho3,36143,35
Lebanon2009Samuel Maoz:imdb:TSPDT2,75162,94
Lebedyne ozero. Zona1990Yuri Ilyenko:imdb:joachimt3,80103,59Image
L'Eden et après1970Alain Robbe-Grillet:imdb:hurluberlu3,67333,60Image
Legend1985Ridley Scott:imdb:dirty_score2,11272,39
Leningrad Cowboys Go America1989Aki Kaurismäki:imdb:zomgmouse2,96253,05
Lenny1974Bob Fosse:imdb:filmbantha3,81263,70Image
Les amoureux sont seuls au monde1948Henri Decoin:imdb:twodeadmagpies4,5043,72
Les antiquités de Rome1991Jean-Claude Rousseau:imdb:St. Gloede4,64144,17Image
Les créatures1966Agnès Varda:imdb:Umbugbene3,13163,19
Les dernières fiançailles1973Jean Pierre Lefebvre:imdb:boss05063,67123,53
Les films rêvés2010Eric Pauwels:imdb:Pretentious Hipster4,80104,15Image
Les mains négatives1978Marguerite Duras:imdb:Mauries3,29173,31
Les maîtres du temps1982René Laloux:imdb:matthewscott83,44253,41
Les misérables1934Raymond Bernard:imdb:revote4,15273,96Image
Les ordres1974Michel Brault:imdb:revote4,00193,80Image
Les parents terribles1948Jean Cocteau:imdb:Umbugbene3,45113,40
Les rendez-vous d'Anna1978Chantal Akerman:imdb:revote3,95373,84Image
Les visiteurs du soir1942Marcel Carné:imdb:zomgmouse3,88333,77Image
Lettre d'un cinéaste à sa fille2002Eric Pauwels:imdb:revote3,94173,75Image
Lettres d'amour1942Claude Autant-Lara:imdb:Opio3,7173,51
Lewat Djam Malam1954Usmar Ismail:imdb:Melvelet3,1383,23
L'homme qui ment1968Alain Robbe-Grillet:imdb:Melvelet3,57303,52
Liang Shan Bo yu Zhu Ying Tai1963Han Hsiang Li:imdb:revote3,18173,23
Lie huo qing chun1982Terry Tong, Patrick Tam:imdb:prodigalgodson2,45202,70
Life Is Sweet1990Mike Leigh:imdb:zomgmouse3,45333,43
Lifeboat1944Alfred Hitchcock:imdb:Dolwphin3,40503,39
L'immortelle1963Alain Robbe-Grillet:imdb:St. Gloede3,92363,81Image
Linda Linda Linda2005Nobuhiro Yamashita:imdb:flip3,47173,43
L'Inde fantôme1969tvMiniSeries:imdb:revote4,1193,74Image
Liza, a rókatündér2015Károly Ujj Mészáros:imdb:cinephage3,15133,22
Local Color1977Mark Rappaport:imdb:beavis4,10103,76Image
Lonely Are the Brave1962David Miller:imdb:revote3,81423,73Image
Lord of the Dance/Destroyer of Illusion1985Richard Kohn:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity4,8363,97:repeat:
L'orribile segreto del Dr. Hichcock1962Riccardo Freda:imdb:frbrown2,19212,50
Los lunes al sol2002Fernando León de Aranoa:imdb:TSPDT2,4492,86
Los peloteros1951Jack Delano:imdb:lineuphere4,0023,46
Lou xia de fang ke2016Adam Tsuei:imdb:Onderhond4,5023,56
Love Serenade1996Shirley Barrett:imdb:MrCarmady3,0083,17
User avatar
Onderhond
Posts: 6849
Joined: December 23rd, 2012, 7:00 am
Contact:

#508

Post by Onderhond »

01. 2,76 - 14 - Herutâ sukerutâ
02. 3,33 - 03 - Hot Gimmick: Girl Meets Boy
03. 3,33 - 06 - Kurôn wa kokyô wo mezasu
04. 3,56 - 02 - Lou xia de fang ke

At least this one has a decent score :P
User avatar
RogerTheMovieManiac88
Posts: 2012
Joined: February 4th, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Westmeath, Ireland
Contact:

#509

Post by RogerTheMovieManiac88 »

I thought 'La poison' was a cert to make the cut, haha... Cynical, darkly cutting comedy and one of Guitry's best. It deserves a higher score...

I have to say (in spite of my reservations about the Bayesian average) that the list of successful films is as good - if not better - than ever.
That's all, folks!
User avatar
OldAle1
Donator
Posts: 6025
Joined: February 9th, 2017, 7:00 am
Location: Dairyland, USA
Contact:

#510

Post by OldAle1 »

Looks like I am on a roll this year

Ángel de fuego 3.25 / 4 / 3.30
Khesht va Ayeneh 3.67 / 25 / 3.58
Krakatit 3.67 / 18 / 3.56
Le signe du lion 3.60 / 30 / 3.54 - thanks Rohmer mafia!

Three for four is better than I'd have allowed myself to dream.
AB537
Posts: 1340
Joined: April 21st, 2018, 6:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada
Contact:

#511

Post by AB537 »

RogerTheMovieManiac88 wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 10:32 pm I thought 'La poison' was a cert to make the cut, haha... Cynical, darkly cutting comedy and one of Guitry's best. It deserves a higher score...

I have to say (in spite of my reservations about the Bayesian average) that the list of successful films is as good - if not better - than ever.
I'm also surprised about La Poison, watched it about a week ago and it was probably my best first time viewing in 2021 ... and with a director who has done well in this poll before. Also agreed on this year's results, I think a significant improvement over the last couple of years.
User avatar
zzzorf
Posts: 1246
Joined: April 14th, 2018, 6:00 am
Location: Kempsey, NSW, Australia
Contact:

#512

Post by zzzorf »

Not to bad results for me so far but plenty more to come since most of mine were clumped later on in the ballet.

1. Grzeli nateli dgeebi - 2.87 (17 votes)
2. Hævnens Nat - 3.37 (10 votes)
User avatar
Carmel1379
Donator
Posts: 4631
Joined: February 21st, 2014, 7:00 am
Contact:

#513

Post by Carmel1379 »

Angel Glez wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 10:05 pm [tr][td]Lord of the Dance/Destroyer of Illusion[/td][td]1985[/td][td]Richard Kohn[/td][td]:imdb:[/td][td]Perception de Ambiguity[/td][td]4,83[/td][td]6[/td][td]3,97[/td][td]:repeat:[/td][/tr]
Nice holdover.

(To the moderators: Don't post my last few posts.)
arritame no yume nikki & I suppose I’ll have to add the force of gravity to my list of enemies
User avatar
Carmel1379
Donator
Posts: 4631
Joined: February 21st, 2014, 7:00 am
Contact:

#514

Post by Carmel1379 »

Lord of the Dance/Destroyer of Illusion - Nice holdover :wub:
arritame no yume nikki & I suppose I’ll have to add the force of gravity to my list of enemies
User avatar
Carmel1379
Donator
Posts: 4631
Joined: February 21st, 2014, 7:00 am
Contact:

#515

Post by Carmel1379 »

La coquille et le clergyman - I'm very happy this one got a thumbs up! :poshclap:
arritame no yume nikki & I suppose I’ll have to add the force of gravity to my list of enemies
matthewscott8
Donator
Posts: 2096
Joined: May 13th, 2015, 6:00 am
Contact:

#516

Post by matthewscott8 »

Angel Glez wrote: May 3rd, 2021, 10:05 pm
TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
La vie à l'envers1964Alain Jessua:imdb:matthewscott84,0083,67Image
This is a very pleasant surprise. I had thought a lot more people would have seen this, it had a niche following on one of the forums I was on years ago. Also nice that score is so high it would have got in on old system.

First official check on it too :)

Some other very pleasant surprises in the French list too :) La nuit fantastique was a nom of mine in 2019 that didn't come close to the threshold then.

Monsieur Ale, La Signe de Lion is one of those canonical films that you find surprising when they're even eligible for this game, great to see it in (ditto The House is Black).
Last edited by matthewscott8 on May 4th, 2021, 8:55 am, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
beavis
Posts: 2930
Joined: June 20th, 2011, 6:00 am
Location: Amsterdam, Netherlands
Contact:

#517

Post by beavis »

La vie nouvelle and Les rendez-vous d'Anna are top 25 all time material for me!
Le brasier ardent was one of the best films I saw in the challenge last month
L'Eden et après and L'immortelle are some of the best Robbe-Grillet movies I am happy to see included
and finally
Local Color, the first of my nominations to make it!!

lot of French movies in this batch indeed, but that might be because of all the Le and La names
User avatar
Mario Gaborović
Posts: 3744
Joined: April 11th, 2014, 6:00 am
Location: Pančevo
Contact:

#518

Post by Mario Gaborović »

I'm begging for Los peloteros' subtitles for years, and if the person who nominated this film reads it, please do it yourself! Otherwise it'll stay in obscurity forever.
User avatar
Angel Glez
Posts: 2360
Joined: April 2nd, 2012, 6:00 am
Location: Spain
Contact:

#519

Post by Angel Glez »

TitleYearDirectorsURLNominatorAMVWA
Love with the Proper Stranger1963Robert Mulligan:imdb:George Eastman4,09113,77Image
Luan qing chun2008Chi-Yuarn Lee:imdb:Onderhond6,0013,63
Lucky Star1929Frank Borzage:imdb:revote4,02443,92Image
Luk e-san1982Vichit Kounavudhi:imdb:Angel Glez3,3333,33
Lumière d'été1943Jean Grémillon:imdb:revote3,71213,61Image
Ma vie de Courgette2016Claude Barras:imdb:Fergenaprido3,40303,39
Macbeth1948Orson Welles:imdb:Ebbywebby3,92263,78Image
Maciste all'inferno1962Riccardo Freda:imdb:frbrown2,6382,98
Made in Abyss2017tvSeries:imdb:flavo50004,5043,72
Mademoiselle1966Tony Richardson:imdb:pitchorneirda3,19163,24
Mafioso1962Alberto Lattuada:imdb:RolandKirkSunglasses4,00173,79Image
Magino Story: Raising Silkworms1977Shinsuke Ogawa:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity5,3333,88:repeat:
Mahô shôjo Madoka magika: Puella Magi Madoka Magica2011tvMiniSeries:imdb:mjf3143,2053,28
Majo no takkyûbin1989Hayao Miyazaki:imdb:ChrisReynolds3,62533,58Image
Makala2017Emmanuel Gras:imdb:Teproc4,0023,46
Malpertuis1971Harry Kümel:imdb:frbrown2,90203,02
Mama, ich lebe1977Konrad Wolf:imdb:Nathan Treadway4,0013,40
Man jeuk2008Johnnie To:imdb:revote3,21193,25
Mandala1981Kwon-taek Im:imdb:flip3,44253,41
Mandara1971Akio Jissôji:imdb:Melvelet3,53193,47
Manderlay2005Lars von Trier:imdb:pitchorneirda3,38293,37
Man's Favorite Sport?1964Howard Hawks:imdb:Gordon_Gekko3,13243,18
Marg Yazdgerd1982Bahram Beizai:imdb:revote4,08133,79Image
Margot at the Wedding2007Noah Baumbach:imdb:TSPDT2,41222,65
María Candelaria (Xochimilco)1944Emilio Fernández:imdb:Dolwphin3,19163,24
Marinetti1969Albie Thoms:imdb:weirdboy4,40103,92Image
Mark of the Vampire1935Tod Browning:imdb:twodeadmagpies1,93272,25
Martha1974Rainer Werner Fassbinder:imdb:RolandKirkSunglasses4,13313,97Image
Martin pleure2017Jonathan Vinel:imdb:Mauries1,8362,69
Marty1955Delbert Mann:imdb:revote3,55493,52
Mascara1983Henri Pachard, Roberta Findlay:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac883,6763,47
Maskerade1934Willi Forst:imdb:revote4,17293,99Image
Massacre1956Louis King:imdb:jdidaco3,6763,47
Matthias et Maxime2019Xavier Dolan:imdb:cayh3,23133,27
Mayak2006Mariya Saakyan:imdb:toromash2,69132,94
Mayis Sikintisi1999Nuri Bilge Ceylan:imdb:pitchorneirda3,00173,11
Mean Creek2004Jacob Estes:imdb:Lakigigar2,69162,90
Mechta1943Mikhail Romm:imdb:Wille4,0083,67Image
Medan staden sover1950Lars-Eric Kjellgren:imdb:zhangalan3,6053,43
Mélo1986Alain Resnais:imdb:RolandKirkSunglasses3,48253,44
Mémoire des apparences1986Raoul Ruiz:imdb:Hunziker3,64143,53
Meng xing xue wei ting1991Chun-Ku Lu:imdb:longsilence4,6733,69
Merci la vie1991Bertrand Blier:imdb:cinephage3,4053,36
Mercuriales2014Virgil Vernier:imdb:Ivan07164,4053,74:repeat:
Merrill's Marauders1962Samuel Fuller:imdb:Hawk3,36143,35
Mes séances de lutte2013Jacques Doillon:imdb:zzzorf2,8883,10
Meshi1951Mikio Naruse:imdb:revote3,94343,82Image
Michael2011Kathrin Resetarits, Markus Schleinzer:imdb:filmbantha3,6793,51
Midvinterblot1946Gösta Werner:imdb:twodeadmagpies2,60302,75
Milano calibro 91972Fernando Di Leo:imdb:toromash3,39313,38
Mil-jeong2016Jee-woon Kim:imdb:AB5372,61182,83
Mimi wo sumaseba1995Yoshifumi Kondô:imdb:monclivie3,69453,63Image
Mind Game2004Masaaki Yuasa, Kôji Morimoto:imdb:monclivie3,65343,59Image
Mirt Sost Shi Amit1975Haile Gerima:imdb:prodigalgodson4,06173,83Image
Misshandlingen1969Lars Lennart Forsberg:imdb:insomnius3,30103,31
Mizu no naka no hachigatsu1995Gakuryû Ishii:imdb:Mauries3,73153,59Image
Mizu no onna2002Hidenori Sugimori:imdb:Onderhond4,8053,90:repeat:
Mo1983Chih-Hung Kuei:imdb:flavo50003,50143,44
Moana2016Don Hall, Ron Clements, Chris Williams, John Musker:imdb:Teproc2,89372,97
Mogholha1973Parviz Kimiavi:imdb:revote3,92123,68Image
Mon oncle Antoine1971Claude Jutra:imdb:revote3,64283,57Image
Monangambé1968Sarah Maldoror:imdb:RogerTheMovieManiac882,3392,80
Monday2000SABU:imdb:Onderhond3,87153,68Image
Mononoke2007tvMiniSeries:imdb:mjf3143,6733,42
Monpti1957Helmut Käutner:imdb:Hawk3,35173,35
Monsieur Vincent1947Maurice Cloche:imdb:pitchorneirda3,00103,15
Moon Blink2015Rainer Kohlberger:imdb:funkybusiness3,5773,44
Motherless Brooklyn2019Edward Norton:imdb:Teproc2,81162,99
Ms .451981Abel Ferrara:imdb:revote3,37383,36
Muerte de un ciclista1955Juan Antonio Bardem:imdb:revote3,59413,54Image
Mula sa kung ano ang noon2014Lav Diaz:imdb:revote3,63273,56Image
Münchhausen1943Josef von Báky:imdb:Hunziker3,35173,35
Munekata kyôdai1950Yasujirô Ozu:imdb:lineuphere3,50143,44
Murder by Death1976Robert Moore:imdb:Gordon_Gekko3,00343,06
Murder on the Orient Express1974Sidney Lumet:imdb:George Eastman2,98513,03
Murder, My Sweet1944Edward Dmytryk:imdb:revote3,81483,74Image
Museum Highlights: A Gallery Talk1989Andrea Fraser:imdb:revote2,21142,62
Mutter Küsters' Fahrt zum Himmel1975Rainer Werner Fassbinder:imdb:Ebbywebby3,73263,64Image
My Architect2003Nathaniel Kahn:imdb:TSPDT2,6053,05
My Dinner with Andre1981Louis Malle:imdb:Jimi Antiloop3,48483,46
My Dog Tulip2009Paul Fierlinger, Sandra Fierlinger:imdb:sol3,3363,33
Mythscape: Remembering The End Of The World1996Ben Ged Low:imdb:Perception de Ambiguity6,0013,63
N.Y., N.Y.1957Francis Thompson:imdb:Hunziker2,79292,91
Na wylot1973Grzegorz Królikiewicz:imdb:Carmel13793,93283,80Image
Nae meorisokui jiwoogae2004John H. Lee:imdb:monclivie3,20103,26
Nain souruzu2003Toshiaki Toyoda:imdb:cayh3,5063,40
Naissance des pieuvres2007Céline Sciamma:imdb:Labraxas3,29173,31
Naked Spaces: Living Is Round1985T. Minh-ha Trinh:imdb:karldaniel4,3393,86Image
Nakinureta haru no onna yo1933Hiroshi Shimizu:imdb:Lobo López3,3883,35
Nathalie Granger1972Marguerite Duras:imdb:revote3,25203,27
Ne croyez surtout pas que je hurle2019Frank Beauvais:imdb:karldaniel2,91113,09
Near Death1989Frederick Wiseman:imdb:revote4,30103,87Image
Nebulosan1999Eric M. Nilsson:imdb:perceval4,8053,90:repeat:
Neighbors1920Buster Keaton, Edward F. Cline:imdb:revote3,33543,33
Nesting Dolls2019Robbie Snow:imdb:72aicm4,0023,46
Ngo joh ngan gin do gwai2002Johnnie To, Ka-Fai Wai:imdb:longsilence3,25123,28
Niagara1953Henry Hathaway:imdb:AB5373,07433,11
Niewinni czarodzieje1960Andrzej Wajda:imdb:Hunziker3,79243,68Image
Nihon kuroshakai1999Takashi Miike:imdb:flip3,2973,31
Nise daigakusei1960Yasuzô Masumura:imdb:lineuphere3,8673,58
User avatar
Onderhond
Posts: 6849
Joined: December 23rd, 2012, 7:00 am
Contact:

#520

Post by Onderhond »

01. 2,76 - 14 - Herutâ sukerutâ
02. 3,33 - 03 - Hot Gimmick: Girl Meets Boy
03. 3,33 - 06 - Kurôn wa kokyô wo mezasu
04. 3,56 - 02 - Lou xia de fang ke
05. 3,63 - 01 - Luan qing chun
06. 3,90 - 05 - Mizu no onna
07. 3,68 - 15 - Monday

I think this is the first time any of my nominations made it :circle:
Also can anyone explain me what the blue icon (holdover?) means? I don't think I ever bothered with that part of the competition as I never got a film this far.
Post Reply