iCM Forum's Favourite Silent Movies, 2nd edition : Results & Stats

[Lilarcor]

Lovely countdown (posters a nice touch). Need to revisit The Kid, found it too cloying on a first watch. Thanks Tim!

[Lonewolf2003]

Wow, Joan won by 0.43 points. Have we ever had a closer finish at the top of a poll?

I don't think so

[Tim2460]

Wow, Joan won by 0.43 points. Have we ever had a closer finish at the top of a poll?

Last time i hosted an poll, an list posted after the deadline that i have accepted changed the top 1

[Tim2460]

Ok some stats then

54 Voters for 1123 Films

[Tim2460]

Of thoses 1123, 831 were totaly new from last poll.

The highest entry is : A Cottage on Dartmoor (Anthony Asquith) 1929.

[Tim2460]

All voters Number 1 were on the top 300, sorry i couldn't finish pointing them as the film is include on the thread as i like to do.

The top 10 has some surprises and the 1/2 is indeed a very close call.

[Tim2460]

Title	Director	Year	Pos	Delta
La passion de Jeanne d'Arc	Carl Theodor Dreyer	1928	1	+4
Metropolis	Fritz Lang	1927	2	0
Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans	F.W. Murnau	1927	3	-2
The General	Buster Keaton; Clyde Bruckman	1926	4	-1
Sherlock Jr.	Buster Keaton	1924	5	-1
City Lights	Charles Chaplin	1931	6	+4
Das Cabinet des Dr. Caligari	Robert Wiene	1920	7	+5
Chelovek s kino-apparatom	Dziga Vertov	1929	8	-2
Bronenosets Potemkin	Sergei M. Eisenstein	1925	9	-2
Körkarlen	Victor Sjöström	1921	10	+10

[Tim2460]

Here are the Country Origin of the top 300 :

USA	130
France	56
Germany	42
Soviet Union	20
Japan	12
UK	8
Sweden	6
Italy	4
Russia	4
Belgium	3
Czechoslovakia	2
Denmark	2
USA, France	2
Australia, UK	1
Austria, Germany	1
Brazil	1
China	1
France, Spain	1
France, Switzerland	1
Netherlands	1
Portugal	1
Sweden, Denmark	1
UK, Sweden	1

[Tim2460]

The top 20 Directors with the more film on top 300 :

Buster Keaton & Others	20
Charles Chaplin	10
Fritz Lang	8
Georges Méliès	8
D.W. Griffith	7
F.W. Murnau	7
Victor Sjöström	7
Ernst Lubitsch	6
Marcel L'Herbier	6
Erich von Stroheim	5
Georg Wilhelm Pabst	5
Jean Epstein	5
Louis Feuillade	5
Yasujirô Ozu	5
Buster Keaton	4
Carl Theodor Dreyer	4
Frank Borzage	4
Fred C. Newmeyer; Sam Taylor	4
Germaine Dulac	4
Aleksandr Dovzhenko	3

[Teproc]

It looks like movies #239 to #237 are missing from the countdown.

[Tim2460]

....Must have been confused of the talkative M @239

inserted the 238 & 237 on the thread : good catch teproc.

We're working with moderation team to choose between 250 and 300 film list.

When decided i'll post the 2 Lists @ ICM

[Tim2460]

Final List is 250 Film Long.

It was a little long to work doubt about the Half Life.

https://www.icheckmovies.com/listsettin ... d+edition/

[Tim2460]

And the full List

https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/icm+ ... t/tim2460/

[beasterne]

Final List is 250 Film Long.

It was a little long to work doubt about the Half Life.

https://www.icheckmovies.com/listsettin ... d+edition/

Getting a 404 error for this one. The full list works fine though.

[Tim2460]

Final List is 250 Film Long.

It was a little long to work doubt about the Half Life.

https://www.icheckmovies.com/listsettin ... d+edition/

Getting a 404 error for this one. The full list works fine though.

hmmm ... not me

https://www.icheckmovies.com/listsettin ... d+edition/

[Lonewolf2003]

Final List is 250 Film Long.

It was a little long to work doubt about the Half Life.

https://www.icheckmovies.com/listsettin ... d+edition/

Getting a 404 error for this one. The full list works fine though.

hmmm ... not me

https://www.icheckmovies.com/listsettin ... d+edition/

Cause the link goes to the edit page, not the list page itself, it doesn't work for others but does work for you.

[Lonewolf2003]

correct link: https://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/icm+ ... n/tim2460/

[Tim2460]

Good catch Lone

[pitchorneirda]

I'm glad you kept the half-life at 30 Nice job Tim