Page 1 of 4

iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 5:38 pm
by Lonewolf2003
iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies
:circle: Results :circle:
Image


These are our favorite movies from South Asia. Eligible countries were Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka.

Half-life is 20. Because there would be too many just 2 votes movies in it otherwise, I decide to make it just a top 75.

Please feel free to discuss the list, the films, and any entries that you're happy or unhappy about, whether you submitted a list or not, but please try to be courteous when doing so. When quoting a post with images it's best if you remove the image unless it's directly relevant to what you're posting.

Nominations topic

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 5:39 pm
by Lonewolf2003
Reserved

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 5:40 pm
by Lonewolf2003
Nothing to see here. Till I recaclulated

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 5:42 pm
by Lonewolf2003
There are 4 two votes movies in the list.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 6:03 pm
by Lonewolf2003
Nothing to see here. Till I recalculated

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 6:37 pm
by jvv
This is going to be a countdown with lots of movies I've never heard of. :thumbsup:

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 7:04 pm
by Lonewolf2003
Nothing to see here. Till I recalculated

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 7:29 pm
by maxwelldeux
When did you download the lists? Because I added Sholay to mine on Friday, so I would have been a third voter on that one.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 8:03 pm
by TajSamKojiJesam
Also I'm pretty sure I had Wisdom Tree on the list from the very start.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 8:06 pm
by mjf314
Maybe all of the iCM lists failed to download?

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 27th, 2020, 8:10 pm
by Lonewolf2003
mjf314 wrote:
April 27th, 2020, 8:06 pm
Maybe all of the iCM lists failed to download?
Yes, they did. I forgot to check if I had all lists downloaded correctly. Will redo this when I have time. I hope to have time tomorrow. But probably won't get around to it till Wednesday. People can still add list or change their list, till I redownload them. Just let me know here or in the nominations topic if you did so.

Sorry.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 3:36 am
by Fergenaprido
No worries Lonewolf. Does this mean we might get a Top 100 after all? I was surprised that it would only be 50 films.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 10:46 am
by RogerTheMovieManiac88
A top 100 would be cool. Films that only appear on one ballot would, I think, be overwhelmingly likely to add to the list if participants ranked them very highly.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 11:04 am
by Onderhond
RogerTheMovieManiac88 wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 10:46 am
A top 100 would be cool. Films that only appear on one ballot would, I think, be overwhelmingly likely to add to the list if participants ranked them very highly.
I agree with this so much :whistling:

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 12:26 pm
by sol
Onderhond wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 11:04 am
RogerTheMovieManiac88 wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 10:46 am
A top 100 would be cool. Films that only appear on one ballot would, I think, be overwhelmingly likely to add to the list if participants ranked them very highly.
I agree with this so much :whistling:
+2

That said, I wouldn't wanted a list that contained a lot of films on just a single ballot, but if it takes two or three single-ballot films in order for us to get a decent length (top 100) list for this poll, I would totally support including them. :thumbsup:

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 2:36 pm
by Lonewolf2003
No, one votes won't be in it. Cause what is high for someone who f.e. submitted a list of 5 titles only? Very high ranked films might be of some value if everyone submitted very long list and is very knowledgeable about the subject. With this polll with the many very short lists with lots of people who only skimmed the top of the ice of the top of the iceberg of South Asian cinema, they aren't imho.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 3:04 pm
by Onderhond
Lonewolf2003 wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 2:36 pm
Cause what is high for someone who f.e. submitted a list of 5 titles only?
I submitted a 1-film list, #64 in my all-time favorites list :D

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 3:30 pm
by Fergenaprido
Lonewolf2003 wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 2:36 pm
No, one votes won't be in it. Cause what is high for someone who f.e. submitted a list of 5 titles only? Very high ranked films might be of some value if everyone submitted very long list and is very knowledgeable about the subject. With this polll with the many very short lists with lots of people who only skimmed the top of the ice of the top of the iceberg of South Asian cinema, they aren't imho.
That's fair. Sounds like we could at least get a Top 75, though, and still not encounter 1-vote films, based on your original post. We've had a few forum lists of that length.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 3:32 pm
by Fergenaprido
Onderhond wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 3:04 pm
Lonewolf2003 wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 2:36 pm
Cause what is high for someone who f.e. submitted a list of 5 titles only?
I submitted a 1-film list, #64 in my all-time favorites list :D
Old Ale also included that film in his list, so there's a good chance it will make it :lol:

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 3:38 pm
by Onderhond
Hah, we are so much alike ... :D

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 6:00 pm
by RogerTheMovieManiac88
Yeah. I can see that point of view as to the depth of individual lists and kind of agree, Lonewolf.

I was kind of in IMDb Classic Film Board-mindset, where in the year-by-year polls the top film in a five-strong list got 5 points and the top film in a twenty-strong list received the full complement of 20 points. I'd been somewhat overlooking the scoring here on ICM Forum. Much as I'd love my #1 to make the list, I can see that under this scoring system all 1-vote films would get the same number of points and thereby all make the list. It would run the risk of being a bit of a free-for-all and possibly dilute the end list.

I think, on reflection, that you've probably made the right decision.

Would like to see as full a list as possible, though! Don't know whether Fergenaprido's suggestion of 75 might be a possibility?

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 6:48 pm
by Lonewolf2003
RogerTheMovieManiac88 wrote:
April 28th, 2020, 6:00 pm
Yeah. I can see that point of view as to the depth of individual lists and kind of agree, Lonewolf.

I was kind of in IMDb Classic Film Board-mindset, where in the year-by-year polls the top film in a five-strong list got 5 points and the top film in a twenty-strong list received the full complement of 20 points. I'd been somewhat overlooking the scoring here on ICM Forum. Much as I'd love my #1 to make the list, I can see that under this scoring system all 1-vote films would get the same number of points and thereby all make the list. It would run the risk of being a bit of a free-for-all and possibly dilute the end list.

I think, on reflection, that you've probably made the right decision.

Would like to see as full a list as possible, though! Don't know whether Fergenaprido's suggestion of 75 might be a possibility?
Since I missed all iCM lists, which by my quick count are 9 votes, there is a high possibility the list will be larger than a top 50. A top 75 seems likely, Hopefully even a top 100. Don’t know for sure yet, cause haven’t recalculated yet.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 7:12 pm
by RogerTheMovieManiac88
Nice. From the few titles that had been provisionally released yesterday, this seems to be shaping up as a fascinating list.

Looking forward to the resumption!

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 28th, 2020, 7:18 pm
by mathiasa
Yes! I hoped something like this would happen, I watched and even added 4 titles to my list after the deadline. Now, all that that's left for my is to watch the official Indian movies on Netflix, starting with Lagaan now.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 4:14 pm
by Lonewolf2003
Okay, here we go again. It became a top 75 now. Half-life is still 20. There are 7 two-votes movies in the list.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 4:17 pm
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#75 Syngué sabour, pierre de patience [The Patience Stone] (Atiq Rahimi, 2012)
144.89 points, 164 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
Caracortada (#22)
Smoover (#2)

Image

#74 Agraharathil Kazhuthai [Donkey in a Brahmin Village] (John Abraham, 1977)
145.41 points, 72 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
3 votersShow
insomnius (#29)
joachimt (unranked>6)
kingink (#26)

Image

#73 Before My Eyes (Mani Kaul, 1989)
149.29 points, 103 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
3 votersShow
mathiasa (#18)
Perception de Ambiguity (#26)
TajSamKojiJesam (#20)

Image

#72 Pratidwandi [The Adversary] (Satyajit Ray, 1970)
151.94 points, 124 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
3 votersShow
insomnius (#27)
OldAle1 (#27)
Smoover (#11)

Image

#71 Naan Kadavul (Bala, 2009)
153.85 points, 44 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
beavis (#4)
Perception de Ambiguity (#14)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 5:02 pm
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#70 Masaan [Fly Away Solo] (Neeraj Ghaywan, 2015)
162.45 points, 181 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
Caracortada (#7)
Fergenaprido (#7)

Image

#69 Bhuvan Shome [Mr. Shome] (Mrinal Sen, 1969)
164.58 points, 99 checks, official lists: 4 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Gorro (#13)
insomnius (#20)
RogerTheMovieManiac88 (unranked>12)
sushantv10 (#53)

Image

#68 Jonaki (Aditya Vikram Sengupta, 2018)
165.91 points, 14 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
beavis (#9)
Perception de Ambiguity (#4)

Image

#67 Amma Ariyan [Report to Mother] (John Abraham, 1987)
166.93 points, 52 checks, official lists: 2 :imdb:
3 votersShow
insomnius (#15)
Perception de Ambiguity (#42)
TajSamKojiJesam (#7)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 6:02 pm
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#66 Anand (Hrishikesh Mukherjee, 1971)
183.03 points, 633 checks, official lists: 2 :imdb:
3 votersShow
Fergenaprido (#20)
Gorro (#9)
sushantv10 (#18)

Image

#65 Pura Handa Kaluwara [Death on a Full Moon Day] (Prasanna Vithanage, 1997)
183.65 points, 14 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
lineuphere (#5)
sol (#2)

Image

#64 Gangs of Wasseypur (Anurag Kashyap, 2012)
185.23 points, 1283 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Gorro (#33)
hurluberlu (#10)
OldAle1 (#10)
sushantv10 (#83)

Image

#63 Kramasha [To Be Continued] (Amit Dutta, 2007)
186.57 points, 112 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
3 votersShow
OldAle1 (#12)
Perception de Ambiguity (#24)
rnilsson19 (#10)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 7:03 pm
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#62 Asha Jaoar Majhe [Labour of Love] (Aditya Vikram Sengupta, 2014)
191.34 points, 33 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
3 votersShow
beavis (#3)
insomnius (#36)
Perception de Ambiguity (#12)

Image

#61 Earth (Deepa Mehta, 1998)
192.7 points, 246 checks, official lists: 2 :imdb:
3 votersShow
Fergenaprido (#11)
kingink (#25)
Smoover (#8)

Image

#60 Andhadhun (Sriram Raghavan, 2018)
193.3 points, 464 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
2 votersShow
maxwelldeux (#1)
sol (#3)

Image

#59 On the Move (S.N.S. Sastry, 1970)
196.59 points, 7 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
Perception de Ambiguity (#1)
rnilsson19 (#2)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 7:14 pm
by Perception de Ambiguity
Lonewolf2003 wrote:
April 29th, 2020, 4:17 pm
#71 Naan Kadavul (Bala, 2009)
153.85 points, 44 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
beavis (#4)
Perception de Ambiguity (#14)
Having watched the film recently I'm very sure that the posted screenshot isn't from 'Naan Kadavul'. How about one of these as a replacement:
SpoilerShow
Image
Image
Image

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 7:33 pm
by Lonewolf2003
Perception de Ambiguity wrote:
April 29th, 2020, 7:14 pm
Lonewolf2003 wrote:
April 29th, 2020, 4:17 pm
#71 Naan Kadavul (Bala, 2009)
153.85 points, 44 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
2 votersShow
beavis (#4)
Perception de Ambiguity (#14)
Having watched the film recently I'm very sure that the posted screenshot isn't from 'Naan Kadavul'. How about one of these as a replacement:
SpoilerShow
Image
Image
Image
Thanks. I adjusted the screenshot.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 8:03 pm
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#58 Nainsukh (Amit Dutta, 2010)
196.72 points, 14 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
3 votersShow
insomnius (#33)
rnilsson19 (#1)
TajSamKojiJesam (#14)

Image

#57 Ankur [Ankur: The Seedling] (Shyam Benegal, 1974)
199.44 points, 142 checks, official lists: 3 :imdb:
3 votersShow
Cocoa (#9)
mathiasa (#3)
RogerTheMovieManiac88 (unranked>12)

Image

#56 Kummatty [The Bogeyman] (Govindan Aravindan, 1979)
200.95 points, 52 checks, official lists: 2 :imdb:
4 votersShow
beavis (#24)
insomnius (#23)
Mysterious Dude (#8)
Perception de Ambiguity (#35)

Image

#55 Nazar (Mani Kaul, 1990)
209.53 points, 18 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
3 votersShow
beavis (#2)
insomnius (#40)
Perception de Ambiguity (#5)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 8:44 pm
by mathiasa
#57 Ankur [Ankur: The Seedling] (Shyam Benegal, 1974)

is the last movie I added after the deadline. Good to see I made an impact here, it‘s such a good movie.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 9:08 pm
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#54 Wisdom Tree (Rajan Khosa, 1986)
211.71 points, 3 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
3 votersShow
Perception de Ambiguity (#6)
rnilsson19 (#6)
TajSamKojiJesam (#25)

Image

#53 Monsoon Wedding (Mira Nair, 2001)
225.46 points, 2936 checks, official lists: 7 :imdb:
5 votersShow
Caracortada (#1)
jeff_v (#17)
Mysterious Dude (#34)
Smoover (#31)
sushantv10 (#140)

Image

#52 Madhumati (Bimal Roy, 1958)
226.34 points, 154 checks, official lists: 2 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Cocoa (#11)
jeff_v (#27)
RogerTheMovieManiac88 (#9)
sushantv10 (#28)

Image

#51 Himalaya - l'enfance d'un chef [Himalaya] (Eric Valli, Michel Debats, 1999)
229.97 points, 246 checks, official lists: 2 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Caracortada (#23)
hurluberlu (#12)
kingink (#9)
Mysterious Dude (#28)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 29th, 2020, 9:09 pm
by Lonewolf2003
That's a nice number to stop at for today.

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 30th, 2020, 8:03 am
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#50 Ashad Ka Ek Din [One Day Before the Rainy Season] (Mani Kaul, 1971)
234.04 points, 15 checks, official lists: 0 :imdb:
3 votersShow
insomnius (#10)
Perception de Ambiguity (#11)
RogerTheMovieManiac88 (#4)

Image

#49 Dhrupad (Mani Kaul, 1983)
235.9 points, 23 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
4 votersShow
insomnius (#14)
Perception de Ambiguity (#38)
rnilsson19 (#13)
TajSamKojiJesam (#8)

Image

#48 Mati Manas [The Mind of Clay] (Mani Kaul, 1986)
241.12 points, 19 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
3 votersShow
Perception de Ambiguity (#3)
rnilsson19 (#14)
TajSamKojiJesam (#6)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 30th, 2020, 9:05 am
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#47 Maya Darpan [Mirror of Illusion] (Kumar Shahani, 1972)
245.52 points, 46 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
4 votersShow
beavis (#15)
insomnius (#31)
Perception de Ambiguity (#15)
TajSamKojiJesam (#5)

Image

#46 Osama (Siddiq Barmak, 2003)
250.7 points, 902 checks, official lists: 3 :imdb:
5 votersShow
Caracortada (#9)
hurluberlu (#13)
kingink (#23)
lineuphere (#15)
sushantv10 (#143)

Image

#45 The Namesake (Mira Nair, 2006)
255.98 points, 757 checks, official lists: 1 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Caracortada (#12)
Gorro (#6)
hurluberlu (#21)
Smoover (#19)

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 30th, 2020, 9:33 am
by beavis
so it's all Mani Kaul now and al Ray towards the top? :)
If popularity wasn't such a big factor in listmaking like this, I quess the two would be more 'realistically' mixed throughout the entire list

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 30th, 2020, 10:11 am
by joachimt
Some images aren't loading for me. They appear to be all the images hosted on icmforum.com. Do others see them?

Re: iCM Forum's Favorite South Asian Movies; Results

Posted: April 30th, 2020, 10:12 am
by Lonewolf2003
"Image

#44 Titas Ekti Nodir Naam [A River Called Titas] (Ritwik Ghatak, 1973)
258.12 points, 194 checks, official lists: 3 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Cocoa (#13)
mathiasa (#5)
Mysterious Dude (#15)
OldAle1 (#25)

Image

#43 Kaagaz Ke Phool [Paper Flowers] (Guru Dutt, 1959)
265.56 points, 392 checks, official lists: 6 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Gorro (#11)
joachimt (unranked>6)
mathiasa (#19)
OldAle1 (#9)

Image

#42 3 Idiots (Rajkumar Hirani, 2009)
271.89 points, 9452 checks, official lists: 3 :imdb:
4 votersShow
Cocoa (#18)
Fergenaprido (#24)
mjf314 (#4)
sol (#7)